Abstract:It is well established that monitoring one's memory performance involves engaging in metacognitive monitoring and activating the frontal cortex. Judgments of Learning (JOLs) are individuals' assessments of the likelihood of remembering a specific item on a future test, usually occurring after learning and before testing. An ongoing debate exists regarding whether participants' metacognitive monitoring is based on a single process or two distinct processes when making JOLs. In this study, we investigated the electrophysiological correlates of JOLs induced by an episodic memory task in 38 adult participants. Participants completed a word pairs memory task and rated their memory performance after remembered whole items. We observed that participants with high judgments of learning had faster reaction times compared to those with low judgments of learning. The electrophysiological results revealed that low judgments of learning were associated with a more negative frontal-central N400-600 amplitude, while high judgments of learning were associated with a larger frontal-parietal slow wave amplitude. Furthermore, low judgments of learning exhibited greater theta band event-related synchronization (θ-ERS) and beta band event-related desynchronization (β-ERD) during the metacognitive monitoring phase compared to high judgments of learning. Brain-behavior correlations also indicated a relationship between the 600–1000 component and behavioral performance, highlighting differential effects between high and low JOLs when making metacognitive monitoring ratings. These findings extend previous research and suggest that the formation of JOL ratings involves two distinct stages: the first stage involves obtaining retrieval fluency cues (frontal-central N400-600 amplitude), while the second stage involves utilizing these cues for metacognitive monitoring (frontal-parietal slow wave amplitude). Varying item familiarity and degrees of retrieval familiarity contribute to differences in JOL ratings. In summary, this study provides compelling evidence for a two-stage process in metacognitive monitoring ratings from both neurophysiological and brain-behavior correlation perspectives.

Learning from errors: Exploration of the monitoring learning effect

Errorless, Errorful, and Retrieval Practice for Naming Treatment in Aphasia: A Scoping Review of Learning Mechanisms and Treatment Ingredients

Learning from errors: Distinct neural networks for monitoring errors and maintaining corrects through repeated practice and feedback

The role of word knowledge in error detection: a challenge to the broken error monitor account of dyslexia

Error monitoring under working memory load: An electrocortical investigation

Cognitive functions supporting learning over time in naming treatment for aphasia.

Toward a mechanistic understanding of the role of error monitoring and memory in social anxiety

The influence of error detection and error significance on neural and behavioral correlates of error processing in a complex choice task

Theoretical Accounts of the Monitoring Mechanism in L1 and L2 Production

Monitoring speech production and comprehension: Where is the second-language delay?

Monitoring in Language Perception: Mild and Strong Conflicts Elicit Different ERP Patterns

Eyetracking during picture naming predicts future vocabulary dropout in progressive anomia

Errorless and errorful learning in people with aphasia across novel-object pairing and word retrieval tasks

Effects on and consequences of responses to errors: Results from two experimental studies

Conflict monitoring in speech processing: An fMRI study of error detection in speech production and perception

Post-error Adjustments Depend Causally on Executive Attention: Evidence from an Intervention Study.

Reality monitoring and metacognitive judgments in a false-memory paradigm

Neural dynamics of metacognitive monitoring: a dual-stage perspective on judgments of learning

Comprehension Monitoring during Reading: An Eye-tracking Study with Children Learning English as an Additional Language

Error-monitoring: A predictor of future reading skills? A 3-year longitudinal study in children

Self-initiated self-repairs of connected speech and novel vocabulary learning during the first year of recovery from aphasia: four longitudinal case studies