Pro/Con: should children visit patients in an intensive care unit (ICU)?
K. Capitulo,S. Barchue,A. Morgan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/NMC.0b013e3182370fcc
Abstract:In 1995, my sister suffered a stroke. The undiagnosed arteriovenous malformation in her brain ruptured, which resulted in paralysis on her right side and a coma for 3 of the 10 days she spent in the intensive care unit (ICU). This was quite a traumatic experience for my family, especially because the doctors gave us no hope of recovery. My sister and my son have a close, wonderful relationship, and I knew that because of this bond he should visit her. However, at the time, children were not allowed in the ICU. This means that children miss out on participating in some of life’s most important teaching moments, observing how families weather storms. By visiting a critically ill patient, the child comes to understand that change has occurred, that family bonds are still strong, and why the family routine and behavior are changing (Borges, Genaro, & Monteiro, 2010). Otherwise, the child is left to fantasize, assume, worry, and even become fearful because reality is hidden and they do not know exactly what to believe. That is why, in my opinion, children should absolutely be allowed in the ICU, on a case-by-case basis. Children are more resilient than we give them credit for, and in certain cases, although momentarily traumatic, an ICU visit may even allow closure if it is a last good-bye of a loved one. Children also often lift and lighten heavy environments, so for the patient and family it may be a very good thing to have a child among them. Nonetheless, ICUs have debated this topic for many years, and currently many have policies in place and strict guidelines to follow if and when children visit the ICU (Ihlenfeld, 2007). In preparing children for visits in the ICU it is necessary to be cognizant of the child’s relationship with the patient. The children should want to visit and not be forced or coerced to do so. It is important to explain and prepare children as best as possible, so that the emotional and psychological effects are lessened. Preparing the child for machines they might see, new smells, sounds they might hear, and other physical attributes that will be present or are particular to the patient’s condition is of the utmost importance. Details such as time limitations should be explained: For example, one may say “Susie, now you can only see your grandmother for 20 minutes. She needs her rest, but she is very much looking forward to seeing you.” Although adults may worry that the ICU experience could be traumatic for the child, just the opposite may be true. One study has shown that children’s fears actually lessened after visiting their loved one in the ICU (Davidson et al., 2007). My experience with my sister resulted in some changes when I returned to the facility where I was the head nurse in the ICU. The visiting hours had been 12 noon–2 p.m. and 5 p.m.–8 p.m.; visitors were allowed in twos for 10 minutes and no children were allowed. After reading the literature and contemplating the human effects of restricted visiting, this changed to a 24/7 visiting hours, and children were allowed to visit. Having gone through the experience from a patient perspective I was able to see the importance of access, support, and just being there to comfort. These changes were made to ensure that the loved ones of the patients could have access to the patient, bring all their support to the patient, and be available to comfort the patient as much as was needed. Decisions always have to be based on what is in the patient’s best interest. This does not change when it comes to children visits. When it is in the patient’s best interest, when families are supportive, and when children are well prepared, an ICU visit can be an excellent life experience for a child. If done well, it can be a most rewarding experience for all and when done exceptionally well, even more so for the patient and child involved. Looking back, I should have made sure that my son be allowed to visit his aunt all those years ago.