Homology among acid proteases : Comparison of crystal structures at 3 A resolution of acid proteases from Rhizopus chinensis and Endothia parasitica ( x-ray diffraction / inhibitor binding / enzyme cleft )
E. Subramanian,I. Swan,Ma-feng Liu,D. Davies,A. J,Jenkins,J. I.,Tickleo,T. Blundell
Abstract:The molecular structures of two fungal acid proteases at 3 A resolution have been compared, and found to have similar secondary and tertiary folding Tse enzymes are bilobal and have a pron c cleft between the two loes. This cleft has been identified as the active site region from inhibitor binding studies. The results of the comparison are discussed in terms of homology among the acid proteases in general. The acid proteases form an interesting and well-defined class of enzymes They include the mammalian enzymes pepsin and chymosin (rennin), and a number of fungal enzymes such as those from Rhizopus chinensis, Endothia parasitica, and Penicillium janthinellum (see refs. 1 and 2). These enzymes are all characterized by molecular weights in the region of 35,000, and pH optima for catalytic action in the range of 1.5-5.0. They share the property of being inhibited by.epoxy compounds and by diazonium compounds in the presence of Cu2+ ions (3, 4). Their catalytic activities have been studied extensively and shown to involve two aspartic acid residues [Asp 32 and Asp 215 in the pepsin sequence (5)]. They are all inhibited by a microbial oligopeptide, pepstatin, an acid-protease-specific inhibitor obtained from culture filtrates of Streptomyces (6-9). They all possess essentially similar substrate specificity, preferring hydrophobic residues on both sides of the scissile bond. In addition, their catalytic action appears to involve extended subsite interactions with several amino acid side chains of the substrate (1, 2). The complete amino acid sequence has been determined for porcine pepsin (5), and limited sequence information is available for several other acid proteases (10-12). These data reveal similarity in sequence and suggest there is homology among the various acid proteases. In particular, the residues immediately adjacent to the two catalytically important aspartic acid residues appear to be identical in all the cases that have been examined (see ref. 1). X-ray diffraction analyses are in progress for several of the acid-proteases and preliminary low-resolution maps have been presented for pepsin at 5 A (13), the Endothia parasitica acid protease at 5.2 A (14), the Rhizopus chinenss enzyme at 5.5 A (15), and the Penidllium janthinellum enzyme at 6 A (16). Here we present the preliminary results of two independent crystal structure analyses at 3.0 A resolution of the enzymes from Rhizopus chinensis and Endothia parasitica, together with a comparison of their structures. X-ray structure determination The crystal structures of the acid proteases from Rhizopus chAens and Endothi paramtica have been determined. MiR (multiple isomorphous replacement) methods were used for the Rhizopus enzyme, and MiER plus analous scattering was used for that from Endothda paraitica. From electon-density maps, practically the entire peptide backbone of the single polypeptide chain has been traced for both enzymes A brief description of the structure analysis for each enzyme follows. The Crystal Structure of the Acid Protease from Rhizopus chinensis. The enzyme was isolated and crystallized ten years ago by Fukumoto et al. (17). The enzyme used here was obtained commercially from Miles Laboratories. Conditions for obtaining crystals suitable for x-ray analysis have been described (18). The crystals are orthorhombic, spacegroup P212121, with unit cell dimensions of a = 60.3, b = 60.7, and c = 107.0 A. There is one molecule per asymmetric unit and the solvent content is about 56%. The low-resolution x-ray analysis (15) showed clearly that the molecule was bilobal and that there was a large cleft between the lobes. A 3 A electron-density map (figure-of-merit = 0.78) was calculated for the enzyme using the heavy-atom derivatives shown in Table 1. Because the amino acid sequence is not available, we were dependent on the continuity of the electron density to trace the polypeptide backbone, and most of the backbone can be followed in this way. A large number of the amino acid side chains are clearly visible. In a few places, however, particularly at bends in the bac e, there are breaks in the density that result in some uncertainties in the chain connectivity. The chain tracing is also somewhat equivocal near the base of the cleft, where the two lobes come in close contact and there are several bridges in the density that presumably result from hydrogen bonding. Nevertheless, the continuity is generally quite reasonable and provides a good overall picture of the molecular configuration. Three-hundred twenty-four a-carbon positions could be assigned; the amino acid composition also suggests 324 residues. The known sequence for the NH2-terminal 39 residues (11, 12) could be fitted to an end of the polypeptide chain that was therefore assigned to be the NH2-terminus (Fig. la). This assignment locates the catalytically active Asp 35 in a loop at the base of the cleft. Adjacent to this loop, but attached to the other lobe on the other side of the cleft, is a similar loop containing the residues around 215. it is interesting to note that Asp 215 is the other catalytically active residue in pepsin. Fig. la is a stereo drawing of the a-carbon backbone of the Rhizopus enzyme. The molecule is mostly made up of antiparallel pleated sheet structure with little helix. The prominent 556 t Present address: Department of Chemistry, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland. § Present address: Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Department of Crystallography, Birkbeck College, London University, Malet Street, London WCIE 7HX, England. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 74 (1977) 557 Table 1. Heavy-atom derivatives used in calculating 3 A electron-density map for Rhizopus chinensis acid protease