Medicine bridges scientific facts and human values.

D. Bates

1982-03-15

Canadian Medical Association Journal

Abstract:The need for periodic, and increasingly frequent, consideration of the relationship between science and medicine is occasioned by two features of our world. The first is that major changes in our perception both of the nature of science and of the process of advancement of scientific knowledge have occurred over the past 20 years. And the second is that physicians are confronted everywhere by reassessments of the role of medicine in our society, and confronted by accusations that the medical profession misunderstands aspects of its proper role in society. These criticisms have been articulated most recently in the Reith lectures in Britain.'"2 Sometimes such reassessments of medicine embody the accusation that modern medicine contains too much science and technology and too little humanity; and we also find ourselves under attack because medical technology, if adopted without forethought, may turn out to be too expensive for our society to sustain. As major recipients of state resources in the modern world, we necessarily find ourselves in an arena in which such questions can properly be asked. These two factors have led me to reconsider some special aspects of the inter-relationship between science and medicine. In what way has our perception of science been changing? The falsity of making sharp distinctions between basic and applied science is now generally recognized, though this is not to say that applied and