Efficacy of a targeted genetic screening program for adolescents.

L. Mccabe

1996-10-01

Abstract:Screening programs have historically faced a burden not demanded for other interventions until recently-demonstrated cost-effectiveness. Implementation of newborn screening for phenylketonuria (PKU) in the 1960s depended on the development of the Guthrie test for detection of elevated blood phenylalanine at a cost of -$1-$2/sample, including program infrastructure expenses (American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Genetics 1989). State and provincial legislatures were persuaded to approve this first publicly supported screening program on the basis of state disability dollars saved by prevention of mental retardation through early treatment of infants with PKU. Addition of other disorders, such as hypothyroidism and sickle-cell disease, to the newborn-screening battery depended on the development of a low-cost test that would be cheaper to provide for every newborn than long-term care for an untreated, affected child. An alternative to population-based screening is targeted screening. In this issue of the Journal, Mitchell et al. report on how they provide education, screening, and counseling of students of Mediterranean origin in Montreal senior high schools in a search for carriers for f3-thalassemia (Mitchell et al. 1996 [in this issue]). A similar program is offered to Ashkenazi Jewish high school students, in a search for Tay-Sachs disease. All students at the high schools attend an informational program that includes an introduction to the principles of genetics; a description of genetic diseases with varying frequencies depending on ethnicity, including 1-thalassemia, cystic fibrosis, sickle-cell disease, and Tay-Sachs disease; and the rationale for genetic screening. The student and a parent must both consent to giving a blood sample for screening for either P-thalassemia or TaySachs disease. Screening reports are presented in a confidential manner, directly to the student. Carriers are contacted by telephone, with offers of additional infor-