The Glycemic Index1

T M Wolever,Thomas M. S. Wolever
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1159/000417536
2024-05-18
World review of nutrition and dietetics
Abstract:Different starchy foods produce different glycemic responses when fed individually, and there is evidence that this also applies in the context of the mixed meal. Methods of processing, and other factors unrelated to the nutrient composition of foods may also have major effects on the glycemic response. The reason for differences in glycemic response appears to relate to the rate at which the foods are digested and the many factors influencing this. The glycemic index (GI) is a system of classification in which the glycemic responses of foods are indexed against a standard (white bread). This allows the results of different investigators to be pooled. GI values also depend upon a number of nonfood-related variables. The method of calculation of the glycemic response area is most important, but the method of blood sampling and length of time of studies also may have effects. Variability of glycemic responses arises from day-to-day variation in the same subject and variation between different subjects. There is less variability between the GI values of different subjects than there is within the same subject from day to day. Therefore, the mean GI values of foods are independent of the glucose tolerance status of the subjects being tested. Potentially clinically useful starchy foods producing relatively flat glycemic responses have been identified, including legumes, pasta, barley, bulgur, parboiled rice and whole grain breads such as pumpernickel. Specific incorporation of these foods into diets have been associated with reduced blood glucose, insulin, and lipid levels. Low-GI foods may influence amino acid metabolism although the implications of these are unknown. In addition, low GI foods increase colonic fermentation. The physiologic and metabolic implications of this relate to increased bacterial urea utilization, and to the production and absorption of short chain fatty acids in the colon. The application of the GI to therapeutic diets should be in the context of the overall nutrient composition of the diet. High-fat or high-sugar foods may have a low GI, but it may not be prudent to recommend these foods solely on the basis of the GI. It is therefore suggested that the most appropriate use of the GI is to rank the glycemic effects of starchy foods which would already have been chosen for possible inclusion in the diet on the basis of their nutritional attributes, i.e. low-fat, unrefined carbohydrate.
nutrition & dietetics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects: 1. **The concept and application of glycemic index (GI)**: The paper explores the differences in blood - glucose responses caused by different carbohydrate - containing foods after ingestion, and proposes the concept of glycemic index (GI) to evaluate and classify the blood - glucose responses of these foods. The definition of GI is: the ratio of the area under the blood - glucose increment curve caused by a certain food to the area under the blood - glucose increment curve caused by a standard food (usually white bread) containing the same amount of carbohydrate, multiplied by 100. Through this method, the information about foods in the food table can be supplemented, making the results of different researchers comparable. 2. **The variability of blood - glucose responses**: - **Inter - individual variation**: There are significant differences in the blood - glucose responses of different individuals to the same food, which may be affected by factors such as diabetes status, body weight, age, gender and ethnicity. - **Intra - individual variation**: When the same individual tests the same food at different times, there is also a certain fluctuation in his or her blood - glucose response. 3. **The influence of different methods on the calculation of glycemic index**: - **Calculation method of the area under the curve**: Different calculation methods may lead to different GI values. - **Blood - sampling method**: The time points and frequency of blood sampling will affect the results. - **Duration of the study**: Different durations of the study may also lead to differences in the results. - **Selection of standard food**: Initially, glucose was used as the standard, but later it was found that white bread was more practical. - **Pretest stabilization**: Pretest stabilization using an artificial pancreas is carried out to reduce the inter - individual variation. 4. **Food factors affecting blood - glucose responses**: - **Protein and fat**: These nutrients can affect blood - glucose responses. - **Carbohydrate and fiber**: Different types and contents of carbohydrates and fibers have different effects on blood - glucose responses. - **Anti - nutrients**: Anti - nutrients in some foods may affect blood - glucose responses. - **Starch - nutrient interaction**: The interaction between starch and other nutrients will also affect blood - glucose responses. - **Properties of starch**: Different types of starch have different effects on blood - glucose responses. - **Food processing / cooking**: Processing and cooking methods can change the GI value of foods. - **Maturity and food storage**: The maturity and storage conditions of foods will also affect their GI values. 5. **Prediction of blood - glucose responses in mixed meals and diets**: The paper explores how to predict the blood - glucose responses in mixed meals and daily diets. 6. **Physiological and therapeutic significance of glycemic index**: - **Second - meal effect**: The GI value of the previous meal may affect the blood - glucose response of the next meal. - **Blood - glucose and insulin levels**: Low - GI foods are helpful in maintaining more stable blood - glucose and insulin levels. - **Blood lipids**: A low - GI diet may be helpful in improving blood - lipid levels. - **Amino acid metabolism**: Low - GI foods may affect the metabolism of amino acids. - **Colonic metabolism**: Low - GI foods may affect the metabolic processes in the colon. 7. **Application of glycemic index**: The paper discusses the application of GI in clinical and nutrition, especially in diabetes management and healthy eating. In general, this paper aims to systematically evaluate and classify the blood - glucose responses of different foods, explore various factors affecting blood - glucose responses, and propose GI as a practical tool for guiding healthy eating and diabetes management.