Biochar from animal manure: A critical assessment on technical feasibility, economic viability, and ecological impact
Dilani Rathnayake,Hans‐Peter Schmidt,Jens Leifeld,Jochen Mayer,Carole Alice Epper,Thomas D. Bucheli,Nikolas Hagemann
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/gcbb.13082
2023-07-06
GCB Bioenergy
Abstract:Animal manure, which has been used for centuries to improve soil fertility, poses risks to human, animal, and environmental health due to the increased global expansion of animal husbandry. Conventional manure management methods have limitations in addressing these risks, but pyrolysis, a thermochemical conversion process, shows promise as an alternative treatment. It can reduce the impact of potentially toxic elements, eliminate pathogens and pollutants, and lower emissions, although more research is needed to determine its impact on crop yield and fertilization efficiency. The image was created with BioRender.com. Animal manure has been used to manage soil fertility since the dawn of agriculture. It provides plant nutrients and improves soil fertility. In the last decades, animal husbandry has been significantly expanded globally. Its economics were optimized via the (international) trade of feed, resulting in a surplus of animal manure in areas with intensive livestock farming. Potentially toxic elements (PTEs), pathogenic microorganisms, antibiotic residues, biocides, and other micropollutants in manure threaten animal, human, and environmental health. Hence, manure application in crop fields is increasingly restricted, especially in hotspot regions with intensive livestock activities. Furthermore, ammonia volatilization and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions during manure storage, field application, and decomposition contribute to air pollution and climate change. Conventional manure management scenarios such as composting and anaerobic digestion partially improve the system but cannot guarantee to eliminate sanitary and contamination risks and only marginally reducing its climate burden. Hence, this review discusses the potential of pyrolysis, the thermochemical conversion under oxygen‐limited conditions as an alternative treatment for animal manure providing energy and biochar. Manure pyrolysis reduces the bioavailability of PTEs, eliminates pathogenic microorganisms and organic micropollutants, and reduces GHG emissions. Pyrolysis also results in the loss of nitrogen, which can be minimized by pretreatment, that is, after removing soluble nitrogen fraction of manure, for example, by digestion and stripping of ammonia–nitrogen or liquid–solid separation. However, conclusions on the effect of manure pyrolysis on crop yield and fertilization efficiencies are hampered by a lack of nutrient mass balances based on livestock unit equivalent comparisons of manure and manure biochar applications. Hence, it is essential to design and conduct experiments in more practically relevant scenarios and depict the observations based on the amount of manure used to produce a certain amount of biochar.
energy & fuels,agronomy