The Impact of Consumer Shopping Experience on Consumer Channel Decision
Haiyan Hu,Cynthia R. Jasper
2015-01-01
Abstract:INTRODUCTION Today consumers can make purchases through multiple channels, such as traditional brick and mortar retailers, online retail sites, and catalogs. Although traditional physical stores still contribute to major share of the retail sales, internet sales has grown at a much faster speed, reaching 6 percent of total retail spending in the fourth quarter of 2013, nearly doubling their share from 2006 (Merrick, 2014). While $155 billion worth of consumer goods were bought online in 2009, a far larger portion of offline sales were influenced by online research. Forrester estimated that $917 billion worth of retail sales in 2009 were Web-influenced. It also estimated that online and web-influenced offline sales combined accounted for 42 percent of total retail sales and that percentage will grow to 53 percent by 2014, when the Web will be influencing $1.4 billion worth of in-store sales (Mulpuru et al, 2009). For most Americans, mall is their destination for major purchases. But online retail sites have effectively reduced the mall traffic especially for those with similar types of merchandise. In order to understand consumer decision making process on which channel to shop, it is important to understand their motives that drive them to various venues. Mall research has shown that today's mall patrons are more leisure driven than in the past (Nicholls et al., 2002). Consumers seek entertainment and a sense of community in their trips to malls (Forseter, 2000). Consumers also appear to be drawn to the idea of a return to Main Street which features more social interaction and a communal atmosphere. Therefore, managers of malls implement more value for their customers, not only monetary but experiential value, into the consumers' trips (Mathwick et al., 2001). In other words, mall managers are redefining their business as not just assembler of merchandise or a service provider, but also as an experience stager (Pine & Gilmore, 1999, p. 12). Some center owners have been working toward this direction to create new meanings associated with the shopping experience. For example, malls host a wide range of activities, from fashion shows to children's carnivals to attract families with kids. Teenagers are likely to be drawn to the mall by live concerts and celebrity appearances. Some mall managements organize walking clubs for others to draw people into the mall (Haeberle, 2001). The primary goal of this study is to examine what role consumers' experience plays in their choice of venues between online retail sites and malls. Furthermore, we will investigate whether the decision making of their channel choice varies across the product categories. The results of the study should offer a useful tool to investigate the effectiveness of retailers' efforts and to identify the optimal mix of channels that may help achieve the best financial and experiential outcome. REVIEW OF LITERATURE Consumer Shopping Experience In contrast to the information processing model, advocates of the experiential aspect of consumption recognized the symbolic, hedonic, and aesthetic nature of consumption (Holbrook et al., 1984). Instead of viewing a consumer as a problem-solver focused on a certain goal, the experiential view emphasized that consumers perform tasks in order to pursue pleasure and gain enjoyment. More importantly, three dimensions of experiential consumption were identified: fantasies, feelings, and fun (Holbrook & Hirschman, 1982). A recent study by Tsai (2010) confirmed the managerial importance of each of these three experiential factors. Based on experiential consumption theories, experiential view of retailing takes a different view of the consumer's motivation to shop. Earlier research shows that consumers shop not only to find a better value, but also for social interaction and enjoyment (Tauber, 1995). …