A CONTRIBUTION TO THE STUDY OF ACUTE RHEUMATISM
F. Poynton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.1.3039.371
1919-03-29
British Medical Journal
Abstract:Fig. 11 records the contraction of the tibialis posticus in a case of hysterical contracture whlich had persisted for over twelve months. The muscle was tensely contracted, leading to equino-varus position of the foot, and the conditi6n had begun after injury to the thigh. Unlike true reflex contractures, this condition was cured after a short course of psycho-therapy. It will be seen that the contractions of the affected muscle are of exactly the same length as on the normal side, and it was this observation that led to the adoption of psycho-therapy as the suitable treatment. Conclu8ion&. In the foregoing records I have shown that after injury to a motor nerve the muscles supplied by the injured fibres respond to stimulus with a contraction longer in duration than that of normal muscle, and that this has been observed in every one of the many hundred cases tested. It appears to me that this lengthening of the contraction is due to hyper-excitability in the muscle following a definite sequence of events, though there is an alternative conclusion which I am at present investigating. It is a matter of common knowledge tllat when for some pathological reason the stimulus from the upper motor neurone weakens or ceases, the anterior horn cells of the lower neurone become hyperexcitable, and the muscle tone is increased. In health there must always be a delicate adjustmnent between the irritability of the upper and lower neurones, so that the lower respond in a proper degree to the stimuli passed down from above. For this reason it is a niatural sequence for the lower neurone to become hyperexcitable when for any reason the upper stimijuli become less intense, and we know that in upper neurone impairment this hyperexcitability is increased to a patlhological degree, as shown in tlhe exaggerated reflexes of such cases as cerebral tumour, certain injuries of the cord, etc. There must also be an adjustmnent of irritability between the lower neurone and the muscle. As an instance of lower neurone interruption the most typical case to cite is one of complete division of a nerve. In Fig. 5 the record of the contraction of extensor carpi radialis longior after division of the musculo-spiral nerve shlows a great lengthening of the period of decontraction, and that is exactly what one would expect if the excitability of a mnuscle were increased. That it is not a slowness of contraction is made evidlent by the angle of the upward line shoowing the contraction of the m-luscle. It is true that frequently this upstrolie is more slanted than normiial in tracings of muscles whose nerve supply has been retarded, but this difference is always very slight coinpared with the difference in the length of tile line showing the decontraction, and I ascribe it to slight tissue changes owing to disuse. At any rate, in many cases, as in that shown in Fig. 5, there is no slowing of contraction displayed while the period of decontraction is much prolonged. I think this lengthening of the period of response of paretic muscle is not to be associated with the chronaxie (rapidity of excitability) of a muscle, because it has been abundantly proved by Lapique and others that the chronaxie of these muscles is increased to as miluch as thirty or forty times the normal, whereas I have shown that the response to the stimulus lasts at most three or four times as long as the normal. In fact, the chronaxie would appear to bear no further relation to the contraction of the muscle than the flaslh point of an explosive to the explosion. In the examples exhibited above, it has been shown that when the nerve impulse is slightly retarded, the muuscle responds with a slightly lengthened response; that when the nerve impulse is further retarded, the muscle responds with a furthler lengthening of the response; that whlen the ner-ve retardation reaches a certain point, the mluscle reaches a limit of response beyond which it cannot go, and thlis response is the same in cases of severe nerve compression or of -;emplete division of the nerve.We hate seen also that after suture of the nerve, and its subsequent regeneration, response to faradac stimulus first appears in the muscle, proving the dawn of the new nerve supply. Then after a period the muscle begins to respond first witlh a slight shortening of the contraction, and tlhen, Allowing the gradual establishment of nerve influence, with a gradual further shortening until, following the complete regeneration of the nerve, the muscle response is restored once more to its nornmal length. It is not intended here to dwell upon the great value as an aid to the more exact diagnosis of delicate nerve lesions which is to be found in the phenomena above described, but rather to look upon the subject from a purely scientific standpoint. Having stated that probably the excitability of the muscle is increased as a result of decreased stimulus from the nerve, and that this is in the nature of an attempt at adjustment on the part of the muscle, it now remains to be shown in support of the latter statement that when the excitability of a lower motor neurone is increased that of the muscle is reducedl. For this purpose I hiave selected the three cases given above-one of upper neurone affection, with the exaggerated reflexes common to these cases, andi the others of contracture of the muscle due to reflex irritation, and in each of these cases the duration of response in the affected muscles lhas been shown to be shortened. These instances present a picture of protective hypo-excitability in muscles supplied by hyperexcitable nerves.