Abstract:Physics, as a discipline, has long struggled with pervasive stereotypes and biases about who is capable and can excel in it. Physics also ranks among the least diverse among all science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) disciplines, often cultivating and fostering learning environments that lack inclusivity and equity. Moreover, stereotypes about brilliance, inequitable physics learning environments and the overall physics culture not only impact the experiences and outcomes of students who major in physics, but also those from other STEM disciplines who must take physics courses. Here we undertake a narrative review, delving into research concerning diversity, equity, and inclusion within undergraduate physics education. We concentrate on the experiences of women and persons excluded due to their ethnicity or race (PEERs) in physics, aiming to shed light on the alarming current situation. The review begins with a few concrete examples of exclusionary experiences that research shows are common for women in physics and can reduce their interest or motivation to pursue a physics major. Then, we provide our conceptualization of equity in physics learning environments and describe the frameworks informing the perspective taken in the review. We then discuss issues related to inequities in physics learning environments, including but not limited to inequities in academic performance, participation, and persistence in physics, as well as psychological factors such as physics self-efficacy, perceived recognition, social belonging, mindset beliefs, and others. We also review research on factors commonly associated with the lack of diversity, equity, and inclusion in physics including the lack of role models, stereotypes associating physics with brilliance, and the overall prototypical culture of physics. We emphasize that addressing these systemic issues in physics requires a holistic approach. We conclude with a list of recommendations for physics departments and instructors on how they can play an important role in transforming the physics culture and making the learning environments equitable and inclusive so that all students can engage in learning physics and enjoy it while feeling supported.

Are inequities in self-efficacy a systemic feature of physics education?

Facilitating Problem Solving in a University Undergraduate Physics Classroom: The Case of Students’ Self-Efficacy

The relationship between gender and academic performance in undergraduate physics students: The role of physics identity, perceived recognition, and self-efficacy

Do female physics students benefit from informal physics programs they facilitate?

A mismatch between self-efficacy and performance: Undergraduate women in engineering tend to have lower self-efficacy despite earning higher grades than men

A longitudinal analysis of students' motivational characteristics in introductory physics courses: Gender differences

Investigating society's educational debts due to racism and sexism in student attitudes about physics using quantitative critical race theory

Exploring the pre-instruction gender gap in physics.

How learning environment predicts male and female students' physics motivational beliefs in introductory physics courses

How perception of being recognized or not recognized by instructors as a "physics person" impacts male and female students' self-efficacy and performance

Challenges faced by women and persons excluded because of their ethnicity and race in physics learning environments: Review of the literature and recommendations for departments and instructors

Role of inclusiveness of learning environment in predicting students' outcomes in courses in which women are not underrepresented

Women in physics in the United States: Reaching toward equity and inclusion

The impact of perceived recognition by physics instructors on women's self-efficacy and interest

An equitable and effective approach to introductory mechanics

Gendered performance differences in introductory physics: A study from a large land-grant university

Importance of accounting for student identities and intersectionality for creating equitable and inclusive physics learning environments

Bias in physics peer recognition does not explain gaps in perceived recognition

A Leaky Pipe Dream? A Study of Gender Differences in Undergraduate Physics

Comment on "Examining the effect of counter-narratives about physics on women's physics career intentions"

Equity in college physics student learning: A critical quantitative intersectionality investigation