Pre-pubertal Depressive Stupor

L. Warneke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.154.3.418b

1989-03-01

Abstract:References nepotism; or by older siblings to whom it may be an advantage for younger siblings to be predisposed to self-effacement; or it may be selected in the self evaluative rough-and-tumble of childhood or the adolescent peer-group. These individuals, who are familiar to us in our clinical work, enter and endure adult life with chronic low self-esteem which is often very resistant to treatment. In other patients we can identify a concurrently contingent low self-esteem strategy in the form of a depressive state. Some people respond to stress with elevation of mood, giving them enhanced vigour and competence associated with a rise of self-esteem; others respond with a reduction of mood, giving them reduced vigour and competence associated with lowered self-esteem. Either strategy is effective at dealing with the prototypical interpersonal stress situation in which two equal adversariesare in com petition and neitherwill give way —¿ a situation which we share not only with other primates but with all other vertebrates. In humans the environmental fac tors will be more complex than in animals, and will almost certainly involve the acquisition or loss of allies, so the proximate causation may well be one of loss rather than of manifest competition. The view of depression as a concurrently con tingent low self-esteem strategy is not in conflict with other causative theories of depression, whether they be psychoanalytical, behaviouristic, neurophysiolo gical, or biochemical; nor is calling depression a strategy in conflict with its conceptualisation as dis ease, reaction, or posture (Hill, 1968). It is merely adding the perspective of ultimate (evolutionary) causation to those methods which seek to analyse proximate (immediate) causation.