Abstract:Introduction: Man-machine interfacing remains the main challenge for accurate and reliable control of bionic prostheses. Implantable electrodes in nerves and muscles may overcome some of the limitations by significantly increasing the interface's reliability and bandwidth. Before human application, experimental preclinical testing is essential to assess chronic in-vivo biocompatibility and functionality. Here, we analyze available animal models, their costs and ethical challenges in special regards to simulating a potentially life-long application in a short period of time and in non-biped animals.Methods: We performed a literature analysis following the PRISMA guidelines including all animal models used to record neural or muscular activity via implantable electrodes, evaluating animal models, group size, duration, origin of publication as well as type of interface. Furthermore, behavioral, ethical, and economic considerations of these models were analyzed. Additionally, we discuss experience and surgical approaches with rat, sheep, and primate models and an approach for international standardized testing.Results: Overall, 343 studies matched the search terms, dominantly originating from the US (55%) and Europe (34%), using mainly small animal models (rat: 40%). Electrode placement was dominantly neural (77%) compared to muscular (23%). Large animal models had a mean duration of 135 ± 87.2 days, with a mean of 5.3 ± 3.4 animals per trial. Small animal models had a mean duration of 85 ± 11.2 days, with a mean of 12.4 ± 1.7 animals.Discussion: Only 37% animal models were by definition chronic tests (>3 months) and thus potentially provide information on long-term performance. Costs for large animals were up to 45 times higher than small animals. However, costs are relatively small compared to complication costs in human long-term applications. Overall, we believe a combination of small animals for preliminary primary electrode testing and large animals to investigate long-term biocompatibility, impedance, and tissue regeneration parameters provides sufficient data to ensure long-term human applications.

Ex-vivo systems for neuromodulation: A comparison of ex-vivo and in-vivo large animal nerve electrophysiology

Ex Vivo Whole Nerve Electrophysiology Setup, Action Potential Recording, and Data Analyses in a Rodent Model

Computational modelling of nerve stimulation and recording with peripheral visceral neural interfaces

Comparison between the cervical and abdominal vagus nerves in mice, pigs, and humans

Experimental Testing of Bionic Peripheral Nerve and Muscle Interfaces: Animal Model Considerations

<i>In vitro</i> study of decellularized rat tissues for nerve regeneration

Ex Vivo Human Tissue Functions as a Testing Platform for the Evaluation of a Nerve-Specific Fluorophore

Vagus nerve stimulation in the non-human primate: implantation methodology, characterization of nerve anatomy, target engagement and experimental applications

Physiological activity within peripheral nerves influences neural output in response to electrical stimulation: an in vivo study

A combined cuff electrode array for organ-specific selective stimulation of vagus nerve enabled by Electrical Impedance Tomography

SenseBack - An Implantable System for Bidirectional Neural Interfacing

A unified model of the excitability of mouse sensory and motor axons

Electrophysiological Signal Validation of Regenerative Peripheral Nerve Interface at Nerve Ending: A Preliminary Rat Model Experiment

Evaluation of Extracellular Matrix-Based Nerve Conduits for Long-Gap Peripheral Nerve Repair in a Goat Model

A multi-channel stimulator with an active electrode array implant for vagal-cardiac neuromodulation studies

Exploring an innovative decellularization protocol for porcine nerve grafts: a translational approach to peripheral nerve repair

Spatially selective stimulation of the pig vagus nerve to modulate target effect versus side effect

Ex vivo normothermic perfusion of isolated segmental porcine bowel: a novel functional model of the small intestine

Regeneration in, and properties of, extracted peripheral nerve allografts and xenografts

Simultaneous decoding of cardiovascular and respiratory functional changes from pig intraneural vagus nerve signals

Human organ donor-derived vagus nerve biopsies allow for well-preserved ultrastructure and high-resolution mapping of myelinated and unmyelinated fibers