Oral contraceptives and cardiovascular disease: some questions and answers.

M. Vessey
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.284.6316.615
1982-02-27
British Medical Journal
Abstract:Use of combined oral contraceptives (OCs) has been associated with certain types of cardiovascular diseases (e.g. venous thromboembolism thrombotic stroke myocardial infarction). Nevertheless some researchers have criticized the data supporting this association. Shearman compiled their major criticisms in an article. The 1st criticism concerns the incompatibility of the national trends in cardiovascular mortality with estimates of risk attributable to the pill derived from case-control and cohort studies. However a proper analysis of mortality trends taking into account all relevant facts about OC use shows that the observed patterns are in fact compatible with a wide range of possible risks attributable to the pill. The 2nd point deals with the assertion that excess deaths in pill users have been almost entirely attributed to smoking. However an excess risk of fatal and nonfatal cardiovascular events associated with OC use has been observed both in nonsmokers and in comparisons of users and nonusers of OCs smoking similar number of cigarettes/day. The 3rd point concerns studies showing a relationship between OC use and venous thromboembolism because clinical diagnosis of deep venous thrombosis is unreliable and potentially subject to bias. However these studies have methodological defects and their findings are not conclusive. The final point focuses on the extent to which pill use is related to subarachnoid hemorrhage and whether or not there is a residual excess risk of cardiovascular disease in ex-OC users. With regard to the subarachnoid hemorrhage association the Royal College of General Practitioners found a strong association between OC use and subarachnoid hemorrhage in its cohort study (20 deaths in total relative risk users: nonusers 4.0:1). As to the residual excess risk in ex-OC users some studies suggest an excess risk and others do not. In the past few years recent changes in OC composition may have resulted in subsequent reduction in OC-related mortality.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?