Marine oil spill pollution causes and governance: A case study of Sanchi tanker collision and explosion

Jihong Chen,Zhongjie Di,Jia Shi,Yaqing Shu,Zheng Wan,Lan Song,Weipan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.122978

IF: 11.1

2020-11-01

Journal of Cleaner Production

Abstract:With the uneven oil distribution worldwide and the growing dependency on oil across countries, tanker transportation has gained increasing predominance in oil trade. However, as a dangerous and highly polluting branch of the maritime industry, oil tankers cannot be underestimated in terms of harm of their oil spills. In recent decades, although oil tanker spill accidents have decreased in number, the hazards of their pollution remain. The Sanchi ship accident in 2018 is a typical example. It is of value to explore how to locate the accident causes and propose effective measures to reduce such accidents. This article takes the Sanchi collision and explosion accident as the subject of study and systematically analyzes main factors of the accident using the fault tree analysis method, with strategies for future tanker management proposed. As shown in results, the factors that contributed to the oil tanker accident are quite complicated, with human factors playing a major part structurally. In addition, management, environmental and ship factors also played a part. Finally, corresponding governance strategies are proposed based on the structural relationships between the factors. The research in this article is of guiding significance for shipping companies to reduce tanker oil spills related to ship collision and acts as an important basis for water transportation administrations to make emergency decisions for such tanker oil spills.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: **Analyze the main causes of tanker collisions and explosion accidents, and propose effective management strategies to reduce the occurrence of such accidents**. Specifically, by studying the collision and explosion accident of the "Sanchi" tanker in 2018, the article systematically analyzes various influencing factors of the accident and their inter - relationships, aiming to identify the key factors leading to tanker collisions and explosions, and provide targeted management suggestions for the prevention and treatment of similar accidents in the future.

### Background of the Paper

With the growth of global oil trade, tanker transportation has dominated in the oil trade, but tanker transportation also brings serious marine pollution risks. Although the number of tanker accidents has decreased in recent years, the harm of each accident is still huge. In particular, the collision and explosion accident of the "Sanchi" tanker in 2018 not only caused serious casualties, environmental pollution and economic losses, but also had a long - term impact on the marine ecosystem.

### Research Questions

The core questions of the paper are:
- **How to accurately locate the causes of tanker collision and explosion accidents?**
- **How to propose effective management and prevention measures based on these causes?**

### Research Methods

To answer these questions, the author adopted the **Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)** method to systematically analyze various factors leading to the "Sanchi" accident, and proposed corresponding treatment strategies according to the structural relationships among these factors. Fault Tree Analysis is a method used to identify and evaluate potential failure causes in complex systems, which can help researchers fully understand the causes of accidents.

### Main Findings

Through detailed analysis of the "Sanchi" accident, the research found that the factors leading to the accident are very complex, mainly including the following aspects:

1. **Human factors**: Such as crew's operational errors, lack of safety training, negligence of on - duty personnel, etc.
2. **Management factors**: Such as poor management of the crew by the company and the captain, failure to take emergency measures in a timely manner, etc.
3. **Environmental factors**: Such as complex channel environments, high - density sailing ships, etc.
4. **Ship factors**: Such as the technical condition of ship equipment, improper use of radar and AIS systems, etc.

### Conclusions and Recommendations

Based on the above analysis, the paper proposes the following suggestions:
- **Strengthen the safety training of the crew** to improve their ability to deal with emergency situations.
- **Improve the ship management mechanism** to ensure that the crew remains highly vigilant during their duty.
- **Optimize ship equipment and technology** to ensure the normal operation of navigation equipment.
- **Improve the management of the navigation environment** to reduce the ship density in busy waters.

These measures are of great guiding significance for shipping companies to reduce tanker collision and explosion accidents, and also provide a scientific basis for water traffic management departments so that they can make emergency decisions quickly when similar accidents occur.