Personality Comparison of Airline Pilot Incumbents, Applicants, and the General Population Norms on the 16PF

Sandra V Wakcher,K. Cross,M. Blackman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2466/pr0.2003.92.3.773
IF: 2.3
2003-06-01
Psychological Reports
Abstract:Personality comparisons using Cattell's 16PF were made between 137 pilot incumbents, 81 pilot applicants, and the general population norms. No significant differences were found between the scores on the personality factors for the Pilot Incumbents and the Pilot Applicants. Further, the incumbents and applicants who had previous military training versus those who did not had highly similar personalities. However, on nearly every personality factor a significant difference was found between the general population norms and the sample of Pilot Incumbents and Applicants. The Pilot Incumbent/Applicant group scored significantly more intelligent, emotionally stable, and mature in comparison to the general population norms. We believe that it is the high-risk nature of this occupation that leads applicants, wishing to pursue this field, to assess very carefully their own person-job fit and self-select themselves, thus ultimately producing this very distinct “pilot personality profile” described in 1995 by Bartram.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?