Letter: Nicotine, tobacco substitutes, and smoking habits.

R. Rawbone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.2.6028.177

1976-07-17

British Medical Journal

Abstract:dysfunction, thyroid disease, and hyperprolactinaemia. Five of these patients, who were excluded from the trial, recovered their potency when the underlying abnormality was treated, although they had failed to respond to previous androgen supplements. These patients often felt physically well and had similar putative aetiological factors which were indistinguishable from those in patients with no physical abnormality. In other words they had their fair share of factors regarded as important in aetiology by Masters and Johnson2-acute alcoholic episodes, marital dysharmony, maternal/paternal dominance, religious orthodoxy, premature ejaculation, etc. It is possible that more physical abnormalities were discovered in our patients than in other published series because of advances in endocrine investigations. Masters and Johnson found that 27 patients out of 213 had associated physical disorder of whom only seven were considered to be impotent as the direct result of physical illness. This difference may be accounted for by the selection procedure. We do not wish to detract from the importance of psychological factors, nor do we suggest that improved sexual education for doctors and undergraduates is unnecessary or undesirable. We do not dismiss the possibility of physical illness making patients more vulnerable to psychological stress. What we do suggest is that adequate sophisticated screening for physical, and particularly endocrine, abnormality should be undertaken before patients are subjected to lengthy psychotherapy. C Q MOUNTJOY TERRY F DAVIES