Home-Based, Low-Intensity, Gamification-Based, Interactive Physical-Cognitive Training for Older Adults Using the ADDIE Model: Design, Development, and Evaluation of User Experience
Teerawat Kamnardsiri,Sirintip Kumfu,Peeraya Munkhetvit,Sirinun Boripuntakul,Somporn Sungkarat
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2196/59141
2024-10-31
JMIR Serious Games
Abstract:Background: Declines in physical and cognitive function is a natural biological process, leading to an increased risk of falls. Promising evidence suggests that combined physical-cognitive exercise has beneficial effects in improving both physical and cognitive health. While moderate-to-high exercise intensity is commonly recommended, it might be impractical for older adults facing physical limitations or contraindications. Thus, low-intensity exercise is a viable option. The main barriers to engaging in exercise in older adults include transportation, time, motivation, and enjoyment. To overcome these challenges, a home-based, gamification-based training system may provide an effective approach to enhance exercise adherence. Objective: This study aimed to develop and evaluate the usability of a low-intensity, gamification-based interactive, combined physical-cognitive exercise for older adults in a home-based setting. Methods: The prototype of a game-based physical-cognitive exercise was created following the ADDIE model (i.e., analysis, design, development, implementation, and evaluation) and assessed for user experience in older adults. Fifteen older adults engaged in the game-based physical-cognitive exercise at home for 60 minutes/day, 3 days/week for 4 weeks. The usability of the game-based training system was evaluated using the System Usability Scale (SUS) after completion of a 4-week training. As for satisfaction, the 8-item Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale (PACES) questionnaire was used to assess participants' enjoyment level after 1-week and 4-week training. Descriptive statistics were employed to illustrate the SUS score. A Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to compare the PACES scores between the first week and the end of the 4-week period, with significance set at P < .05. Results: As for experts' consensus, the game-based training consisted of 3 games: Ocean Diver, Road Runner, and Moving and Memorizing, and 3 levels of difficulty: beginner, intermediate, and advanced. A computer vision-based system was selected as the delivery platform for a home setting. The total SUS score for all participants was 87.22 ± 5.76, indicating the user's perception of the usability of a system ranging from good to excellent. At the end of the 4-week training, the total PACES score was significantly greater than the first week, suggesting an improvement in enjoyment (1st week = 44.93 ± 3.99 versus 4th week = 50.53 ± 4.70, P = .001). Conclusions: The prototype of low-intensity, gamification-based interactive physical-cognitive training was designed and developed using the ADDIE model, which included both experts and end-users in the process. The findings showed that the exergame prototype was a usable and practical approach for a home-based setting, enhancing older adults' enjoyment and motivation. The effectiveness of gamification-based training for improving both physical and cognitive health in older adults is still warranted.
public, environmental & occupational health,health care sciences & services,medical informatics