Abstract:Abstract Background Despite being a major advancement in modern medicine, vaccines face widespread hesitancy and refusal, posing challenges to immunization campaigns. The COVID-19 pandemic accentuated vaccine hesitancy, emphasizing the pivotal role of beliefs in efficacy and safety on vaccine acceptance rates. This study explores the influence of efficacy and safety perceptions on vaccine uptake in Italy during the pandemic. Methods We administered a 70-item questionnaire to a representative sample of 600 Italian speakers. Participants were tasked with assessing the perceived effectiveness and safety of each vaccine dose, along with providing reasons influencing their vaccination choices. Additionally, we conducted an experimental manipulation, exploring the effects of four framing messages that emphasized safety and/or efficacy on participants’ willingness to receive a hypothetical fourth vaccine dose. Furthermore, participants were asked about their level of trust in the scientific community and public authorities, as well as their use of different information channels for obtaining COVID-19-related information. Results Our study reveals a dynamic shift in vaccine efficacy and safety perceptions throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, potentially influencing vaccination compliance. Initially perceived as more effective than safe, this assessment reversed by the time of the third dose. Beliefs regarding safety, rather than efficacy, played a significant role in anticipating future vaccinations (e.g., the booster dose). Safety-focused messages positively affected vaccination intent, while efficacy-focused messages showed limited impact. We also observed a changing trend in reasons for vaccination, with a decline in infection-related reasons and an increase in social related ones. Furthermore, trust dynamics evolved differently for public authorities and the scientific community. Conclusions Vaccine perception is a dynamic process shaped by evolving factors like efficacy and safety perceptions, trust levels, and individual motivations. Our study sheds light on the complex dynamics that underlie the perception of vaccine safety and efficacy, and their impact on willingness to vaccinate. We discuss these results in light of bounded rationality, loss aversion and classic utility theory.

Are we saying it right? Communication strategies for fighting vaccine hesitancy

Meeting the challenge of vaccine hesitancy

Combating Vaccine Hesitancy: Teaching the Next Generation to Navigate Through the Post Truth Era

Patient concerns and physician strategies for addressing COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy

The lingering challenge: addressing vaccine hesitancy in a post-pandemic world

Overcoming vaccine hesitancy in low-income and middle-income regions

Vaccine hesitancy, misinformation in the era of Covid-19: Lessons from the past

Digital tools, multidisciplinarity and innovation for communicating vaccine safety in the COVID-19 era

Vaccination hesitancy: To be vaccinated, or not to be vaccinated, that is the question in the era of COVID‐19

Mitigating Misinformation Toolkit: A Medical Student Role-Play Curriculum on Communication Techniques to Facilitate Vaccine Misinformation Conversations

Key factors in complex public health interventions to address vaccine hesitancy using a multidisciplinary approach: the VAX-TRUST project

Strategies to overcome vaccine hesitancy: a systematic review

Promoters and Barriers of Vaccine Hesitancy

Not sure? Handling hesitancy of COVID-19 vaccines

Seasonal and pandemic influenza: the role of communication and preventive strategies

COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy Among US Adults: Safety and Effectiveness Perceptions and Messaging to Increase Vaccine Confidence and Intent to Vaccinate

Navigating vaccine hesitancy: Strategies and dynamics in healthcare professional-parent communication

Strategies for Improving Vaccine Communication and Uptake

A World without Measles and Rubella: Addressing the Challenge of Vaccine Hesitancy

Pathways to informed choices: The impact of freedom of choice and two-sided messages on psychological reactance and vaccination intentions among individuals who express concerns

I want to be safe: understanding the main drivers behind vaccination choice throughout the pandemic