Metabolism, Measurement and Modelling: Understanding and Exploiting Tissue Oxygenation
Sally C. Pias,Qi Wang,Rachel J. Dotson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1113/jp281213
2021-01-01
The Journal of Physiology
Abstract:Oxygen (O2) is so central to metabolism that respiration, itself, could not occur without it. As an outstanding oxidizing agent, O2 is both a crucial metabolite and a toxin. Abundant oxygen supply is a primary driver of oxidative phosphorylation (ATP production), yet overabundance of O2 or generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) can cause critical cellular damage. Due to its central role in energy metabolism, oxygen scarcity has potentially devastating effects. Elaborate mechanisms have evolved to enable cells to sense and respond to oxygen levels. Discoveries related to these mechanisms were recognized by the 2019 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine (Prabhakar, 2020). Notably, sustained hypoxia (low oxygen) is associated with cancerous metabolic phenotypes, especially the widely known ‘Warburg effect.’ The role of oxygen as a toxin has been exploited in anticancer therapeutic strategies, especially tumour radiotherapy. Such strategies utilize O2 present in the tissue to generate relatively stable radical species capable of severe DNA damage. The central metabolic importance of oxygen has led to extensive study of its transport mechanisms, especially convective, haemoglobin-mediated transport in the blood. Even so, oxygen transport at the level of cells and tissues remains poorly understood, due to limitations in experimental techniques for measuring and localizing O2 as well as uncertainty regarding the solubility of oxygen in cellular and interstitial fluids. The International Society on Oxygen Transport to Tissue (ISOTT) has a 48-year history of bringing together diverse researchers to share insights and discoveries related to tissue oxygenation. The ISOTT 2019 annual meeting was generously sponsored by The Journal of Physiology. Fundamental and applied researchers from the USA, Europe, and Asia gathered in Albuquerque, NM, USA for the meeting held 27–31 July 2019. The scientific sessions addressed oxygen metabolism and health monitoring; oxygen measurement and modelling; tumour oxygenation and metabolism; brain oxygenation and function; and interstitium, lymphatics and blood. The society is notably well-represented in the areas of tumour oxygenation and radiotherapy, oxygen measurement technique development, and metabolic monitoring via near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS). The current issue of The Journal of Physiology includes three review articles from leading members of the ISOTT community, reflecting research presented at the ISOTT 2019 meeting. The articles address oxygen metabolism, measurement, and modelling. Peter Vaupel and Gabriele Multhoff revisit the role of oxygen in the Warburg effect, whereby malignant tumours exhibit a metabolic shift toward lactic acid fermentation (Vaupel & Multhoff, 2021). Howard Halpern and colleagues examine techniques of measurement in tumours, with emphasis on recent work coupling 3D hypoxia imaging with radiotherapeutic dose painting (Gertsenshteyn et al. 2021). Sally Pias invokes modelling to reassess the preferential pathway of oxygen diffusion within cells and tissues (Pias, 2021). Below, we consider each article in greater detail. Vaupel and Multhoff review the history and conceptual framework surrounding the Warburg effect (Vaupel & Multhoff, 2021). In particular, they bring to light evidence that challenges and adds nuance to Otto Warburg's original claim (in 1923) that mitochondrial dysfunction in the form of irreversible respiratory injury lies at the heart of enhanced conversion of glucose to lactate observed in malignant tumours. The Warburg effect is often described as ‘aerobic glycolysis,’ as Warburg understood it to entail a shift toward oxygen-independent glycolysis, even in the presence of abundant oxygen. Vaupel and Multhoff point out that such a ‘glycolytic switch’ in tumours is occasionally a result of mitochondrial dysfunction, rendering Warburg's interpretation correct in a minority of cases. However, the authors emphasize that, in most tumours, molecular signalling events lead to the Warburg effect at an early stage in oncogenesis that precedes tumour hypoxia. Therefore, hypoxia is not usually the principal cause of the Warburg effect. Indeed, tumour cell mitochondria usually remain capable of carrying out respiration, such that the rate of oxygen uptake in most malignant tumours does respond to oxygen availability. As such, the article suggests that the Warburg effect is usually oxygen independent, in the sense that oxygen availability is not a primary determinant of the glycolytic switch. Vaupel and Multhoff see the Warburg effect as a central aspect of metabolic reprogramming and a major contributor to malignancy, radio- and chemotherapy resistance, and poor patient outcome. Halpern and colleagues consider techniques for obtaining spatially resolved measurements of oxygen in tumour tissues, as an aid to personalizing radiotherapy treatment to improve tumour control and reduce complications (Gertsenshteyn et al. 2021). Hypoxia promotes radiotherapy resistance, but hypoxia is neither spatially uniform nor temporally fixed. The article highlights work using EPR imaging to generate 3D quantitative maps of tumours. In particular, Halpern and associates recently found success in mouse tumour models by applying a hypoxia threshold of ≤ 10 Torr to the 3D map. In this way, the map was used to establish a radiation ‘dose-painting’ template for applying heavier doses of radiation to resistant/hypoxic areas, while protecting radiation-sensitive/well-oxygenated areas from excessive radiation. Unlike previous efforts using a PET imaging technique to generate a dose-painting template, the EPR-based hypoxia imaging approach enabled improved local tumour control in the mouse models. The success of the EPR-based technique appears to stem from its high degree of accuracy in identifying truly hypoxic tissue regions and avoiding unnecessary irradiation of healthy regions critical to tissue and organ function. The technique appears promising for future use in humans, pending establishment of the spin-label probe's safety and identification of targetable radiation-resistant hypoxic regions within human tumours. The review article in this issue by Pias challenges the common assumption that oxygen diffuses through tissues primarily along water-based (aqueous) pathways and highlights evidence suggesting that cellular lipid-based pathways may dominate (Pias, 2021). Indeed, the resistance posed by aqueous cytosolic and interstitial fluids appears to be greater than that posed by lipids, due to low O2 solubility in water and relatively high solubility in lipids. Pias highlights molecular simulation evidence suggesting that both the solubility and the diffusivity (diffusion coefficient) of oxygen is particularly enhanced at the midplane of lipid bilayers. Such enhancement is amplified by high membrane cholesterol content, which is often found in tumours. Building on earlier works, Pias imagines accelerated ‘channelling’ of oxygen along extended reticular networks formed from plasma and organellar membranes, as well as cellular lipid droplets. The article illustrates three distinct pathways of oxygen diffusion from capillaries to mitochondria within tissue: along cell bodies, through interstitial fluid, and through networked lipids. A simple quantitative model is used to compare the kinetics of oxygen transport along the three pathways. Based on the model, Pias determines that lipid-based diffusion pathways are likely to influence the rate of oxygen delivery to mitochondria within tissues. The magnitude of the rate effect is found to depend strongly on the solubility of oxygen in cytosolic and interstitial fluids, which remains poorly understood. More sophisticated understanding of the spatial distribution and preferential diffusion pathway of oxygen within tissues may open doors to advances in cell culture and tissue engineering, as well as reveal therapeutic strategies to control tissue oxygenation. The three articles in this symposium set are interconnected, although they address distinct aspects of the physiological and pathophysiological significance of oxygen. The first takes a fundamental view of molecular-cellular mechanisms underlying malignant tumour metabolic reprogramming and hypoxia-associated phenotype. The second takes an applied view of tumour hypoxia and associated radiotherapy resistance, seeking strategies to map hypoxic regions and personalize radiotherapy treatment. The third examines the distribution and diffusion of oxygen at the level of molecular and cellular structures, with potential insight into tumour oxygenation and radiotherapy response as well as broader physiological implications. These articles illustrate both the diversity and the interrelatedness of research directions pursued among members of ISOTT. They, further, exemplify the importance and timeliness of ongoing studies of oxygen transport to tissue. We invite readers to delve into the individual articles and to join the society for lively discussions at the ISOTT 2021 annual meeting in beautiful Ascona, Switzerland. The authors acknowledge funding from the Glendorn Foundation.