Party Systems and Political Change in Europe

Larry M. Bartels

Abstract:I examine how party systems in 21 European democracies have shaped, and been shaped by, changes in citizens’ economic and cultural values over the past two decades. I map the distributions of economic and cultural values in each political system over time and across generations, and measure the extent to which supporters of different political parties in each system have distinctive values. I distill three idealtypes of European political systems—Nordic, Catholic, and post-communist—with characteristic configurations of social values, dissensus, and partisan conflict. Dynamic analysis suggests that value change is largely exogenous, while polarization is strongly affected by prior value change, changes in dissensus, and—in the case of societal polarization—changes in party systems. These findings shed light on the nature of the relationship between citizens and parties in European political systems and on the substance of past and potential future political change in Europe. 1 Prepared for presentation at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Chicago, 29 August-1 September 2013. I am grateful to members of the Behavioral Research Workshop in Vanderbilt University’s Department of Political Science for helpful discussion and criticism of a preliminary draft of this report.