Is silence golden? A pilot study exploring associations between children's language environment and their language skills in Estonian-speaking families

Tiia Tulviste,Anni Tamm

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jecp.2021.105096

Abstract:This two-wave longitudinal study explored how Estonian children's language environment relates to their language skills. The Language ENvironment Analysis (LENA) system's automated measures were used as a source of information about children's home language environment. Children's expressive vocabulary was measured via the parent-reported Estonian CDI III (ECDI-III), and language comprehension and production were measured via the examiner-administered New Reynell Developmental Language Scales (NRDLS). The assessments were made 1 year apart at ages 3;0 (years; months) (N = 22) and 4;0 (N = 19). The results revealed wide variability in children's home language environment and language skills. Girls' language production scores were higher; they heard a larger quantity of adult words and spent less time in noisy environments than boys at Wave 2. At Wave 1, children's word count was positively associated with productive language scores, whereas silence was negatively associated with language production and expressive vocabulary. At Wave 2, children who had been more exposed to electronic media scored higher on expressive vocabulary. Distant speech at Wave 1 was positively correlated with language comprehension scores at Wave 2 also when controlling for language comprehension scores at Wave 1. The results, which indicate that distant talk is a positive aspect and silence is a negative aspect of the language environment, highlight the importance of "languagizing" homes also in cultures where silence tends to be more highly valued and talkativeness tends to be less highly valued when compared with English-speaking middle-class families.