8-Year Outcomes of Bilateral Lateral Rectus Recessions versus Unilateral Recess-Resect in Childhood Basic-Type Intermittent Exotropia
The Pediatric Eye Disease Investigator Group,Sean P. Donahue,Danielle L. Chandler,Rui Wu,Justin D. Marsh,Christine Law,Raymond G. Areaux,Fatema F. Ghasia,Zhuokai Li,Raymond T. Kraker,Susan A. Cotter,Jonathan M. Holmes,On behalf of the Pediatric Eye Disease Investigator Group
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ophtha.2023.09.004
IF: 14.277
2023-09-11
Ophthalmology
Abstract:Objective To report 8-year outcomes from a randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing bilateral lateral rectus muscle recessions (BLRc) with unilateral recess-resect (R&R) for childhood intermittent exotropia (IXT). Design Eight-year follow-up of RCT cohort Participants 123 of 197 randomized participants agreed to continue follow-up after the 3-year outcome visit (baseline age 3 to <11 years with basic-type IXT 15-40 prism diopters (Δ) by prism and alternate cover test (PACT), baseline stereoacuity of 400 arcsec or better, no prior surgery) Methods Following the RCT primary outcome at 3 years, annual follow-up from 4 through 8 years with treatment at investigator discretion. Main Outcome Measures Suboptimal surgical outcome by 8 years after randomization, defined as any of the following at any visit: exotropia ≥10Δ by simultaneous prism cover test (SPCT) at distance or near; constant esotropia (ET) ≥6Δ by SPCT at distance or near; loss of near stereoacuity by ≥0.6 log arcsec from baseline; or reoperation. Secondary outcomes included 1) reoperation by 8 years and 2) complete or near-complete resolution at 8 years: exodeviation <10Δ by SPCT and PACT at distance and near and ≥10Δ reduction from baseline PACT at distance and near; ET <6Δ at distance and near; no decrease in stereoacuity by ≥0.6 log arcsec from baseline; no reoperation or nonsurgical treatment for IXT. Results The Kaplan-Meier cumulative probability of suboptimal surgical outcome through 8 years was 68% (55 events among 101 at risk) for BLRc and 53% (42 events among 96 at risk) for R&R (difference = 15%, 95% CI: -2% to 32%, P = 0.08). Complete or near-complete resolution at 8 years occurred in 14% (6/42) for BLRc and 37% (16/43) for R&R (difference = -22%, 95% CI: -44% to -0.1%, P = 0.049). The cumulative probability of reoperation was 30% for BLRc and 11% for R&R (difference = 19%, 95% CI=2% to 36%, P = 0.049). Conclusions Despite no significant difference at primary outcome, the 95% CI did not exclude a moderate benefit of R&R, which together with secondary outcomes, suggests that unilateral R&R followed by usual care may yield better long-term outcomes than BLRc followed by usual care, for basic-type childhood IXT, using our surgical doses.
ophthalmology