Abstract:Background: This paper describes the design, implementation, and process outcomes from three public deliberations held in three tribal communities. Although increasingly used around the globe to address collective challenges, our study is among the first to adapt public deliberation for use with exclusively Indigenous populations. In question was how to design deliberations for tribal communities and whether this adapted model would achieve key deliberative goals and be well received. Methods: We adapted democratic deliberation, an approach to stakeholder engagement, for use with three tribal communities to respect tribal values and customs. Public deliberation convenes people from diverse backgrounds in reasoned reflection and dialogue in search of collective solutions. The deliberation planning process and design were informed by frameworks of enclave deliberation and community-based participatory research, which share key egalitarian values. The deliberations were collaboratively designed with tribal leadership and extensive partner input and involvement in the deliberations. Each deliberation posed different, locally relevant questions about genomic research, but used the same deliberation structure and measures to gauge the quality and experience of deliberation. Results: A total of 52 individuals participated in the deliberations across all three sites. Deliberants were balanced in gender, spanned decades in age, and were diverse in educational attainment and exposure to health research. Overall, the deliberations were positively evaluated. Participant perceptions and external observer datasets depict three deliberations that offered intensive conversation experiences in which participants learned from one another, reported feeling respected and connected to one another, and endorsed this intensive form of engagement. Conclusion: The adapted deliberations achieved key deliberative goals and were generally well received. Limitations of the study are described.

Extending Research Protections to Tribal Communities

Conducting research with Indigenous peoples in Canada: ethical and policy considerations

Codesigning a community-based participatory research project to assess tribal perspectives on privacy and health data sharing: A report from the Strong Heart Study

Scientists and scientific journals should adhere to ethical standards for the use and reporting of data from Indigenous people

Genomic Research and American Indian Tribal Communities in Oklahoma: Learning From Past Research Misconduct and Building Future Trusting Partnerships

American Indian Researcher Perspectives on Qualitative Inquiry About and Within American Indian Communities

Culturally Responsive Opioid and Other Drug Prevention for American Indian/Alaska Native People: a Comparison of Reservation- and Urban-Based Approaches

Navigating University Openness in Research Policy Inconsistent with Indigenous Data Sovereignty: A Case Analysis

A relational framework for microbiome research with Indigenous communities

A New Era of Indigenous Research: Community-based Indigenous Research Ethics Protocols in Canada

Practices of Informing and Consenting in Indigenous Communities: The Case of The Marshall Islands

Encompassing Cultural Contexts Within Scientific Research Methodologies in the Development of Health Promotion Interventions

In Consideration of Indigenous Data Sovereignty: Data Mining as a Colonial Practice

Formative Research and Cultural Tailoring of a Substance Abuse Prevention Program for American Indian Youth: Findings From the Intertribal Talking Circle Intervention

Complicating Narratives: Defining and Deconstructing Ethical Challenges in Community Psychology

The Holding Space: A Guide for Partners in Tribal Research

Ecological research 'in a good way' means ethical and equitable relationships with Indigenous Peoples and Lands

Deliberations with American Indian and Alaska Native People about the Ethics of Genomics: An Adapted Model of Deliberation Used with Three Tribal Communities in the United States

Truth and Reconcilition Commissions and Health Care System Responses for Indigenous Peoples: A Scoping Review

Research with Refugee Populations in North America: Applying the NIH Guiding Principles for Ethical Research

Ethics and Best Practices of Studying Contemporary Human Populations