Cost-efficiency analysis of weapon system portfolios

Jussi Kangaspunta,Juuso Liesiö,Ahti Salo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2012.05.042

IF: 6.4

2012-11-16

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Cost Effectiveness Model and Optimization of Weapon System Based on Cost As an Independent Variable

Lei Gu,Xiangming Xi,Kuangyu Liu,Shuning Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/wcica.2016.7578503

2016-01-01

Abstract:Cost effectiveness analysis is to select the best alternative based on the value of effectiveness, which can be obtained by the life cycle cost. Inspired by the thought of cost as an independent variable (CAIV), this paper attempts to turn the evaluation and decision problem into a programming problem. We estabilish the system effectiveness model with the logarithm method and the cost model with the logistic curve. Then according to the cost effectiveness decision-making criteria, we estabilish cost effectiveness model of the weapon system, which can be approximated by a continuous piecewise linear (CPWL) surrogate model. To solve the obtained problem, we utilize CPWL programming methods. The feasibility of model and optimization is validated by an example of cost effectiveness model of armed helicopter.
Weapons Equipment Portfolios Selection Based on Equipment System Contribution Rates

Liu Peng,Li Jichao,Xia Boyuan,Zhao Danling,Tan Yuejin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.23919/jsee.2021.000050

IF: 1.363

2021-01-01

Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics

Abstract:Equipment selection is an essential work in the re-search and development planning of equipment.The scientific and rational development of weapons equipment portfolios is of con-siderable significance to the optimization of equipment architec-ture design,the adequate resources allocation,and the joint com-bat performance.From the system view,this paper proposes a method of weapons equipment portfolios selection(WEPS)based on the contribution rate of weapon systems,providing a new idea for weapon equipment portfolio selection.Firstly,we analyze the WEPS problem and the concept of the contribution rate under the systems background.Secondly,we propose a combat network modeling method for weapon equipment sys-tems based on the function chain.Thirdly,we propose a WEPS method based on the contribution rate,fully considering the cor-relation relationships between potential weapons and the old weapon systems by the combat network model,under the limit-ation of capability demands and budget resources,with the ob-jective to maximally increasing the combat ability of weapon systems.Finally,we make a case study with a specific WEPS problem where the whole calculation processes and results are analyzed and exhibited to verify the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed method model.
Possibilistic Approaches to Portfolio Selection Problem with General Transaction Costs and A Clpso Algorithm

Xi-li Zhang,Wei-Guo Zhang,Wei-jun Xu,Wei-Lin Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10614-010-9220-4

IF: 1.741

2010-01-01

Computational Economics

Abstract:The structure of portfolio selection depends essentially on the form of transaction cost. In this paper, we deal with the portfolio selection problems with general transaction costs under the assumption that the returns of assets obey LR-type possibility distributions. For any type of transaction costs, we employ a comprehensive learning particle swarm optimizer algorithm to obtain the optimal portfolio. Furthermore, we offer numerical experiments of different forms of transaction costs to illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed model and approach.
The Optimization of Long-Term Dynamic Defense Industry Project Portfolio Management with a Mixed and Holistic Project Prioritization Approach

Hakan Ayhan Dağıstanlı,Aygün Altundaş,Kemal Gürol Kurtay,Yunus Gökmen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13235-024-00602-6

2024-10-30

Dynamic Games and Applications

Abstract:With the developing technology and increasing conflict environment, countries allocate more budgets to defense industry projects every year to protect their lands and be deterrent. Military project management is a separate project management field with its own characteristics. Since defense industry projects include long-term, high-budget and integrated projects, procurement planning must be carried out in an organized manner. Therefore, defense industry projects have a complex structure for decision makers. The concept of project-based procurement in defense management ensures that weapon systems equipped with the latest technology are included in the inventory in appropriate time periods by using scarce resources effectively. In this study, the model was developed to support decision makers in project management decisions at a strategic level in a structure that enables coordinated procurement of main and auxiliary projects under allocated budget constraints and can be spread over years. In the general problem considered, portfolio selection optimization was performed for 16 different land, air and defense projects and 4 auxiliary project types integrated into them for a 10-year dynamic planning period. In this way, a mathematical model was created that decides which project, how many, in which period and with what amount of resource transfer will be completed in a country in the planned period. With the solution of the model, planning was made for a minimum of 119 and a maximum of 168 projects per period. Annual used, transferred, cumulative and initial budgets were presented for each period for planned projects. Accordingly, it was calculated that a used budget of 2.083 million units was needed. While creating the portfolio, the final efficiency values (FEV) obtained from the integration of the total lethality (TLI) and multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) priority values of the weapon systems were added to the model and a methodology original to the literature was presented.

mathematics, interdisciplinary applications
Resilience Evaluation and Optimal Design for Weapon System of Systems with Dynamic Reconfiguration

Zhiwei Chen,Dongpao Hong,Weiwei Cui,Weikang Xue,Yao Wang,Jilong Zhong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ress.2023.109409

2023-05-31

Abstract:The weapon system of systems (WSoS) is a collection of various weapon systems used to achieve a common goal and mission. Stakeholders are committed to lowering design costs while achieving greater resilience. In this paper, we establish a resilience evaluation and optimal design method for WSoS under different attack and reconfiguration strategies that can balance its resilience and cost. Firstly, a WSoS-oriented three-phase resilience model and evaluation algorithm are developed, taking into account resistance, adaptability, and recovery factors. Then, a resilience-based WSoS cost model is presented to assess the cost of new equipment, improved equipment, and resilience-associated costs. Additionally, a resilience-based optimization model is proposed that considers reduced costs and increased resilience. Non-dominated sorting in genetic algorithms: II (NSGA-II) is selected to achieve the Pareto optimal solution. Finally, a typical 5-node formation air defense WSoS is utilized to illustrate the resilience evaluation and optimization design, which can serve as a reference for WSoS design.

engineering, industrial,operations research & management science
Evaluating weapon system using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process based on entropy weight

Don-Lin Mon,Ching-Hsue Cheng,Jiann-Chern Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0165-0114(94)90052-3

IF: 4.462

1994-03-01

Fuzzy Sets and Systems

Abstract:The performance evaluation of weapon systems are multiple criteria decision making problems. The descriptions and judgements on weapon systems are usually linguistic and fuzzy. The traditional method of Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) are mainly used in crisp (non-fuzzy) decision applications with a very unbalanced scale of judgements. To overcome these problems, we will propose a new and general decision making method for evaluating weapon systems using fuzzy AHP based on entropy weight. We will use symmetric triangular fuzzy number 1 to 9 to indicate the relative strength of the elements in the hierarchy, and build fuzzy judgement vectors (matrix) through comparison of the performance scores. We will derive the priority among the alternatives by the entropy weight through the use of interval arithmetic, α-cuts, and index of optimism (the degree of optimism of the decision maker) to estimate the degree of satisfaction of the judgement. In this way it does not require a series of pairwise comparison judgements as required by the traditional AHP method. By multiplying the fuzzy subjective weight vector W̃ with the corresponding fuzzy judgement matrix X̃ (the orderly list of fuzzy judgement vectors x̃·i for every criterion Ci), a fuzzy problem can be solved and a weapon system selection example will be used to illustrate our method and compare it with other methods.

mathematics, applied,statistics & probability,computer science, theory & methods
An operational efficiency evaluation method for weapon system-of-systems combat networks based on operation loop

Jichao Li,Yingwu Chen,Ke-Wei Yang,Chunxiao Fu,Xiaoke Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/SYSOSE.2014.6892491

2014-06-09

Abstract:To meet the demands of the joint operation under the information conditions, the operational effectiveness of a combat network of weapon system-of-systems has become a hot research. In this study, an operational effectiveness evaluation method based on operation loop is put forward. First, we introduce the concepts of operation loop and discuss the weapon system-of-systems combat networks model. Then, a measure called operation loop evaluation index is present to evaluate the operational effectiveness. To verify the feasibility and effectiveness of the given measure, two scenarios: a scenario of edge decreasing and a scenario of node decreasing are designed. We compare the operational effectiveness evaluated by operation loop evaluation index and the radio of the Perron-Frobenius eigenvalue of the network adjacency matrix and the node number (PFE/N) under the two scenarios. Results show that operation loop evaluation index is better in evaluating the operational effectiveness of a combat network.

Engineering,Computer Science
Research on Effectiveness Evaluation Method of Weapon Equipment

Shan Yu Shang,Jia Man Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22158/fet.v3n4p1

2020-09-09

Frontiers in Education Technology

Abstract:Due to the wide application of high and new technology in weapons and equipment, modern weapons present the characteristics of complexity and systematization, and their effectiveness analysis and evaluation are paid more and more attention, which has become an arduous and urgent task in the research of weapon equipment system. Only by using scientific methods and technology to evaluate the effectiveness of various types of weapons and equipment, can we have a profound understanding of the characteristics and application value of weapons and equipment, ensure that the army can give full play to the operational potential of weapons and equipment, improve the operational efficiency, and explore the correct direction of the construction and development of weapons and equipment. Therefore, systematic research on weapon equipment effectiveness evaluation method is a necessary way for every military equipment effectiveness researcher to seek effective and accurate quantitative analysis of weapon equipment effectiveness method.

English Else
Ammunition Type Optimization Based on Damage Ability Matching

Yuan Li,Xianming Shi,Yajuan Li,Wei Xia,Jiangbo Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5934172

IF: 1.43

2021-07-29

Mathematical Problems in Engineering

Abstract:At present, there exist many kinds of new ammunition, with great differences in application occasions. In the process of ammunition preparation, it is usually necessary to configure a variety of ammunition to meet the needs of attacking different targets. It is essentially a multiple criteria decision-making problem to select the appropriate ammunition type for different targets and provide a reliable decision support for accurate ammunition support. On this basis, the matching degree of ammunition target damage ability is selected as the ammunition type optimization standard, the objective weighting method, entropy weight method, is selected to determine the evaluation index weight, and the VIKOR method is used to gather the ammunition type optimization evaluation value, which overcomes the uncertainty caused by subjective weighting and the information loss caused by index value conversion and takes into account the group benefit value and individual regret value. Through an example, the sensitivity analysis of the decision mechanism coefficient in the VIKOR method is carried out, and the results are compared with those of the TOPSIS method to verify the stability and effectiveness of this method in the process of ammunition type optimization.

engineering, multidisciplinary,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications
Evaluation of technological competence and operations efficiency in the defense industry: The strategic planning of South Korea

Jun Gon Lee,Min Jae Park

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2019.101775

Abstract:This research aims to contribute to efficiency improvement by providing the implications for decision-making on continuous defense R&D investment strategies and acquisition methods via analyzing the current position and measuring the efficiency of overall weapon systems on technological competence and operations. This research is distinctive in comparison to previous studies because it is structured in a two-stage DEA analysis for efficiency by distinguishing between the technology and operations of the current eight fields of weapon systems and by adding the external index for government competence and market competence. In 2016, in comparison to the year 2013, the eight major weapon systems' efficiency fields of the overall system of Korea, efficiency of technological competence, and efficiency of operations all increased. This research introduced the input and output variable that fits in with the defense industry by connecting the weapon systems efficiency with the national innovation system and the sectoral innovation system that are both projected in this industry. It also formed the concepts of technological competence efficiency and operations efficiency using the two-stage Network DEA method.
Operational Capability Analysis of Self-Propelled Artillery Based on SPA-AHP Method

Jia Rong-bao

Abstract:The operational capability analysis of self-propelled artillery based on the SPA-AHP method is educed from the relatively decision-making matrixes constructed by the cost indexes, such as firepower response time, overall combat weight, time to emplace, hull exposed area, and the related benefit indexes. The method used to calculate the weight of the AHP of the group-based decision making is compiled by the Matlab software, and the weights of all elements in index layer compared with those in target layer is calculated subsequently. At last, the one-dimensional optimized-cost and tenth-rate-cost matrixes are drawn from the standard matrixes.

Engineering
Portfolio Optimization Model with Transaction Costs

Shu-ping Chen,Chong Li,Sheng-hong Li,Xiong-wei Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s102550200022

2002-01-01

Acta Mathematicae Applicatae Sinica English Series

Abstract:The purpose of the article is to formulate, under the l ∞ risk measure, a model of portfolio selection with transaction costs and then investigate the optimal strategy within the proposed. The characterization of a optimal strategy and the efficient algorithm for finding the optimal strategy are given.
A Comprehensive Survey of Weapon Target Assignment Problem: Model, Algorithm, and Application

Jinrui Li,Guohua Wu,Ling Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engappai.2024.109212

2024-01-01

Abstract:This paper provides an overview of the weapon target assignment problem, which aims to optimize the assignment of weapons to targets in order to maximize weapon damage to targets. The weapon target assignment problem can be viewed as a specialized instance of the optimal resource assignment problem. With the advancement of weapons technology, high-speed and high-lethality missiles have become more advanced, and their tactical applications more diverse. These missiles can strike targets with greater accuracy and improved concealment, posing a significant threat to both attackers and defenders. Consequently, the weapon target assignment problem has become a pressing concern in the field of military offense and defense. Subsequently, researchers worldwide are devoting significant efforts to address the weapon target assignment problem through the utilization of exact algorithms, heuristic algorithms, meta-heuristic algorithms, and artificial intelligence methods. This paper provides a brief review of the weapon target assignment problem development history, formula, solution techniques, and applications. We categorize weapon target assignment problems into four different formulas, considering the complexity of combat scenarios, and summarize various solution methods for each category. Furthermore, we also emphasize the relevance of weapon target assignment problems in national defense applications. Lastly, we conclude by discussing potential avenues for future research in addressing the weapon target assignment problem.
Research on the Effectiveness of Tactical Missile Weapon Systems Based on Energy Big Data

Shan Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/amns-2024-1059

2024-01-01

Applied Mathematics and Nonlinear Sciences

Abstract:Abstract The study of tactical missile weapon systems, particularly their operational efficiency, is increasingly important in modern warfare. These systems are crucial for accurately striking targets and achieving air superiority. The effectiveness evaluation of such missile systems provides a quantitative foundation for both upgrading existing weapons and setting performance benchmarks in combat exercises. This particular topic focuses on the evaluation of tactical missile weapon systems using energy big data. A comprehensive index system is utilized to conduct this evaluation, incorporating methods like fuzzy comprehensive evaluation and analytic hierarchy process. These methods enable both qualitative and quantitative analysis of the capability matrix in the ADC (Aim, Deploy, and Conclude) model. The main objective is to ensure the correctness and effectiveness of the evaluation model. An example analysis is conducted to verify the model’s validity. The results from this analysis indicate a high degree of accuracy in the model’s predictions. The disparity between the actual and expected output results is minimal, with a relative error within 4%. Furthermore, the combat effectiveness grade determined by the model aligns with the actual grade observed, confirming the model’s capability to effectively evaluate the combat effectiveness of surface-to-air missile weapon systems. This research is significant as it provides a reliable and accurate method for assessing the effectiveness of tactical missile systems. Such evaluations are vital for informed decision-making in military strategy and weapon system development. Using energy big data in this context represents a novel approach, reflecting the increasing integration of advanced data analytics in military technology assessments.
Economic Analysis of Two Different Door Architectures

Sebastian K. Fixson,Patrick J. Blanchard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4271/2001-01-3045

2001-10-16

Abstract:In the past, materials selection for automotive components has been managed on a part-by-part basis. As a result, the economics of these selections have often been reduced to comparing material price/property ratios, rather than technological options. More recently, the debate around modular designs and their advantages and disadvantages has shifted the emphasis towards a higher level viewpoint that deals with more complex systems. This approach provides the opportunity to search for new combinations of product architecture and materials that may exploit specific material advantages better than the classic part-by-part replacement. This paper presents the results of an economic analysis for two different door designs. The door designs differ both with regards to their product architectures and with regards to the materials they employ. The economic analysis considers the following process steps: parts fabrication, subassembly, paint, and final assembly (trim) for two production scenarios. The case study reveals several findings. First, the analysis concludes that both door designs offer a potential economic advantage depending on the final production volume. Specifically, the conventional design is considered more appropriate for high volume production, whilst the alternative design is more cost effective at production volumes typical of niche and derivative vehicles. Second, since the choice of design architecture has an influence on all sub systems, meaningful comparisons between the architectures may be made only through the adoption of comprehensive cost models. For example, the case study demonstrates that the choice of certain product architectures can help mitigate disadvantages caused by higher input material costs. Finally, the case study finds that the cost savings from ‘commonization’ of components vary depending on the base production volume.
Research on Operational Effectiveness of Space-Based Weapon and Sensitivity Analysis

Ding Zhou,An Zhang,Huan Chang,Zhenglin Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ihmsc.2016.42

2016-01-01

Abstract:This paper aims at studying the evaluation of operational effectiveness of Space-based weapon through the analysis of main factors that affect the operational effectiveness of Space-based weapon and the establishment of operational effectiveness evaluation system. The sensitivity of important design parameters that significantly affect the operational effectiveness of Space-based weapon is analyzed through sensitivity analysis. For the shortcomings of traditional sensitivity analysis methods, interval mathematics sensitivity analysis method based on clustering genetic algorithms is proposed. The simulation data is statistically analyzed to verify the accuracy of the model. It verified that this method of researching operational effectiveness of Space-based weapon is rational.
Portfolio Analysis in Procurement Contract Management

CHEN Xiang-feng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-7857.2006.02.025

2006-01-01

Abstract:Supply chain risk management is considered as an indispensable tool for business. And the portfolio analysis in procurement contract management, regarded as a innovational tool, should be used to manage business risk. Firstly, the paper introduces the importance about procurement management and the portfolio analysis in contract management; secondly, it provides two kinds of decision-making of contracts , included both procurement strategy based on product portfolio management and procurement tactic based on portfolio theory; thirdly, it put forward the framework of support decision system in terms of the research results above.
A Method to Analyze Operational Efficiency of the Grouped Attackers A Method to Analyze Operational Efficiency of the Grouped Attackers

Jian-liang Ai,Guo-hong QIAN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-0640.2000.03.004

2000-01-01

Abstract:This paper puts forward the principle of operational effectiveness analysis of the groupedattackers (OEAGA) and constructing OEAGA top mathematical models on the basis of the averagedynamic theory ;gives (EI) relationship of the effectiveness indexes with the weapons' EI on the ground andthe EI of the grouped attackers breaking through the air defense;presents the formulas of computing therequired destroyed numbers of attacker,the total flight number of sorties and the total consumption ofweapons during the mission. The results establishes a theoretical base for OEAGA
Improvement plan for cost management system of military executive agencies in supply field

Gakgyu Kim,Hojun Lee,Yongju Cho,Kyoungchan Won

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37944/jams.v5i2.144

2022-08-31

Journal of Advances in Military Studies

Abstract:This paper presents an improvement plan for the cost management system of a military executive agency in the supply field. The military introduced an executive agency system to improve the efficiency of defense operations. As of 2022, 18 units, including the land, sea, and air general supply depots, are being operated as military executive agencies. The first step in improving management efficiency is establishing a cost management system. It is necessary to eliminate inefficient processes, redundant or unnecessary work, and cost information is an approach to improve work efficiency. Currently, military executive agencies manage costs based on arbitrary standards set by the cost manager of each institution instead of systematic standards. Consequently, cost management is superficial and has not led to cost reduction. Furthermore, because the cost management standards are inconsistent, it is impossible to use them for comparing and analyzing the cost information of each institution. In particular, it is recommended that cost information be synthesized and utilized without data omission by establishing a common standard according to the guidelines for calculating corporate logistics costs announced by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport and using the national defense-integrated financial information system. Finally, the application of data-based analytical procedures can improve the efficiency of military operating agencies by identifying abnormal areas and eliminating inefficient processes.
Combat effectiveness and efficiency evaluation of firearm weapon systems in different projectile guidance simulations

Yunyoung Jung,Jonghwan Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37944/jams.v6i1.196

2023-04-26

Journal of Advances in Military Studies

Abstract:We analyze the combat effectiveness and efficiency of the firearm weapon systems with stochastic simulations approach. Such combat effectiveness and efficiency are related with the precision of weapon systems, but the precision varies greatly depending on the projectile guidance method of the weapon system. Thus, this study conducted a stochastic simulation based on a mathematical model considering different projectile guidance methods. The simulation was designed assuming Counter-Artillery Fire, which is an important battle that must be successful in order to achieve a firepower advantage in the early stages of the war, and is suitable for judging the combat effectiveness and efficiency due to the precision of the firearm weapons system. Combat effectiveness and efficiency are judged as the result of damage probability, damage type, and desired shooting frequency, and damage probability and damage type represent combat effectiveness, and desired shooting frequency represents efficiency. The simulation environment deployed and simulated an enemy artillery unit with a size of 1,000m × 750m in the target area (6 guns), and applied the killing range of each firearm weapon system. For the description of the damage, the mathematical models Carlton damage function and the cookie cutter damage function were applied, and Monte Carlo simulation was applied to simulate the uncertainty of the battlefield. The results of the present study can be provided basic data to effectively operate and plan the firearm weapon systems.

Cost-efficiency analysis of weapon system portfolios

Cost Effectiveness Model and Optimization of Weapon System Based on Cost As an Independent Variable

Weapons Equipment Portfolios Selection Based on Equipment System Contribution Rates

Possibilistic Approaches to Portfolio Selection Problem with General Transaction Costs and A Clpso Algorithm

The Optimization of Long-Term Dynamic Defense Industry Project Portfolio Management with a Mixed and Holistic Project Prioritization Approach

Resilience Evaluation and Optimal Design for Weapon System of Systems with Dynamic Reconfiguration

Evaluating weapon system using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process based on entropy weight

An operational efficiency evaluation method for weapon system-of-systems combat networks based on operation loop

Research on Effectiveness Evaluation Method of Weapon Equipment

Ammunition Type Optimization Based on Damage Ability Matching

Evaluation of technological competence and operations efficiency in the defense industry: The strategic planning of South Korea

Operational Capability Analysis of Self-Propelled Artillery Based on SPA-AHP Method

Portfolio Optimization Model with Transaction Costs

A Comprehensive Survey of Weapon Target Assignment Problem: Model, Algorithm, and Application

Research on the Effectiveness of Tactical Missile Weapon Systems Based on Energy Big Data

Economic Analysis of Two Different Door Architectures

Research on Operational Effectiveness of Space-Based Weapon and Sensitivity Analysis

Portfolio Analysis in Procurement Contract Management

A Method to Analyze Operational Efficiency of the Grouped Attackers A Method to Analyze Operational Efficiency of the Grouped Attackers

Improvement plan for cost management system of military executive agencies in supply field

Combat effectiveness and efficiency evaluation of firearm weapon systems in different projectile guidance simulations