‘Warning: Ultra-Processed’ — A Call for Warnings on Foods That Aren’t Really Foods
Trish Cotter,Alexey Kotov,Shuo Wang,Nandita Murukutla
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2021-007240
IF: 8.056
2021-01-01
BMJ Global Health
Abstract:Correspondence to Trish Cotter; tcotter@ vitalstrategies. org © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2021. Reuse permitted under CC BYNC. No commercial reuse. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. It's high time that consumers had the opportunity to see ultraprocessed foods for what they are: foods that are not real foods, containing nutrients but not real nutrition, pervasively marketed by supranational companies offering choices that are not real choices. Despite the robust evidence that links ultraprocessed foods to serious health consequences, our research indicates that the public does not fully understand this group of products, and it suggests that they might be in the dark about the urgent actions that could be taken to prevent its dire harms. Simply put, ultraprocessed foods are foods that can’t be made in your home kitchen because they have been chemically or physically transformed using industrial processes. They are recognisable on the supermarket shelf as packaged foods that are readytoeat, contain more than five ingredients and have a long shelflife. The industrial processing, as well as the cocktail of additives, flavours, emulsifiers and colours they contain to give flavour and texture, make the final product hyperpalatable or more appealing and potentially addictive, which in turn leads to poor dietary patterns. With more than half the total calories consumed in highincome countries coming from ultraprocessed foods and rapid increases in lowand middleincome countries, these products are exposing billions of people to a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, heart disease, stroke, depression and death. 4 9 Your grandparents wouldn’t have used or even recognised them. In the half century or so since ultraprocessed foods became available, diets high in those products have largely displaced traditional and healthier diets, and ultraprocessed foods have been among the most aggressively promoted and marketed products in the world. In addition, their intensive marketing has led to rapidly growing sales in lowand middleincome countries. 10 Worldwide, palates (and brains) have been trained to crave these foods while the food industry invests many millions in formulating and marketing them to be highly desirable. While the term ‘ultraprocessed food’ has gained much attention in the academic and nutrition community over the past 10 years, many advocates have taken to describing these as ‘products’, to indicate that they are not ‘real’ foods but formulations of food substances. Unfortunately, the public remains largely unaware of the risks of consuming them. What do consumers know about ultraprocessed foods? Surveys and qualitative focus groups in Colombia and Brazil have enabled us to gather some insight into public perceptions of ultraprocessed foods (full details in Wang). We found evidence that while people are not familiar with the term ‘ultraprocessed products,’ they recognise the group of products as harmful. That said, these products are also associated with positive emotions, which might be the result of decades of persuasive marketing by the food industry. For instance, a considerable number of people associate the products with satisfying cravings, being tasty and bringing joy. People associate ultraprocessed products with family, social Summary box