The evolutionary dynamics of how languages signal who does what to whom

Olena Shcherbakova,Damián E. Blasi,Volker Gast,Hedvig Skirgård,Russell D. Gray,Simon J. Greenhill

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-51542-5

IF: 4.6

2024-03-29

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Languages vary in how they signal "who does what to whom". Three main strategies to indicate the participant roles of "who" and "whom" are case, verbal indexing, and rigid word order. Languages that disambiguate these roles with case tend to have either verb-final or flexible word order. Most previous studies that found these patterns used limited language samples and overlooked the causal mechanisms that could jointly explain the association between all three features. Here we analyze grammatical data from a Grambank sample of 1705 languages with phylogenetic causal graph methods. Our results corroborate the claims that verb-final word order generally gives rise to case and, strikingly, establish that case tends to lead to the development of flexible word order. The combination of novel statistical methods and the Grambank database provides a model for the rigorous testing of causal claims about the factors that shape patterns of linguistic diversity.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how languages mark "who did what to whom" through different grammatical means. Specifically, the research focuses on three main strategies: case, verbal indexing, and rigid word order. The paper aims to explore the causal relationships among these strategies, especially the relationships between case and verb - final word order and flexible word order. The research uses grammatical data from 1,705 languages around the world and adopts phylogenetic causal graph methods to analyze the evolution process of these language features.

The core questions of the paper are:
1. **The relationship between case and verb - final word order**: Verify whether verb - final word order will lead to the emergence of case.
2. **The relationship between case and flexible word order**: Explore whether case will lead to the development of flexible word order.
3. **The co - occurrence and absence of these features**: Explain why certain combinations of language features are more stable or occur more frequently in historical evolution.

Through these analyses, the paper hopes to reveal the factors behind language diversity, especially how these grammatical features influence and evolve each other in the historical process.