Efficacy of Therapeutic Aquatic Exercise vs Physical Therapy Modalities for Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain
Meng-Si Peng,Rui Wang,Yi-Zu Wang,Chang-Cheng Chen,Juan Wang,Xiao-Chen Liu,Ge Song,Jia-Bao Guo,Pei-Jie Chen,Xue-Qiang Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.42069
2022-01-01
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:IMPORTANCE Therapeutic aquatic exercise is frequently offered to patients with chronic low back pain, but its long-term benefits are unclear. OBJECTIVE To assess the long-term effects of therapeutic aquatic exercise on people with chronic low back pain. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This 3-month, single-blind randomized clinical trial with a 12-month follow-up period was performed from September 10, 2018, to March 12, 2019, and the trial follow-up was completed March 17, 2020. A total of 113 people with chronic low back pain were included in the experiment. INTERVENTIONS Participants were randomized to either the therapeutic aquatic exercise or the physical therapy modalities group. The therapeutic aquatic exercise group received aquatic exercise, whereas the physical therapy modalities group received transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and infrared ray thermal therapy. Both interventions were performed for 60 minutes twice a week for 3 months. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES The primary outcome was disability level, which was measured using the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire; scores range from 0 to 24, with higher scores indicating more severe disability. Secondary outcomes included pain intensity, quality of life, sleep quality, recommendation of intervention, and minimal clinically important difference. Intention-totreat and per-protocol analyses were performed. RESULTS Of the 113 participants, 59 were women (52.2%) (mean [SD] age, 31.0 [11.5] years). Participants were randomly allocated into the therapeutic aquatic exercise group (n = 56) or the physical therapy modalities group (n = 57), and 98 patients (86.7%) completed the 12-month follow-up. Compared with the physical therapy modalities group, the therapeutic aquatic exercise group showed greater alleviation of disability, with adjusted mean group differences of −1.77 (95% CI, −3.02 to −0.51; P = .006) after the 3-month intervention, −2.42 (95% CI, −4.13 to −0.70; P = .006) at the 6-month follow-up, and −3.61 (95% CI, −5.63 to −1.58; P = .001) at the 12-month follow-up (P < .001 for overall group × time interaction). At the 12-month follow-up point, improvements were significantly greater in the therapeutic aquatic exercise group vs the physical therapy modalities group in the number of participants who met the minimal clinically important difference in pain (at least a 2-point improvement on the numeric rating scale) (most severe pain, 30 [53.57%] vs 12 [21.05%]; average pain, 14 [25%] vs 11 [19.30%]; and current pain, 22 [39.29%] vs 10 [17.54%]) and disability (at least a 5-point improvement on the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire) (26 (continued) Key Points Question Is therapeutic aquatic exercise as effective as physical therapy modalities in the management of adults with chronic low back pain? Findings In this randomized clinical trial of 113 individuals with chronic low back pain, therapeutic aquatic exercise had a greater influence on pain, function, quality of life, sleep quality, and mental state than physical therapy modalities after a 3-month intervention, and the effect was present up to the 12-month follow-up. The recommendation rate of therapeutic aquatic exercise was significantly higher than that of physical therapy modalities. Meaning The findings of this trial suggest that therapeutic aquatic exercise is an effective treatment for adults with chronic low back pain. + Visual Abstract + Supplemental content Author affiliations and article information are listed at the end of this article. Open Access. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC-BY License. JAMA Network Open. 2022;5(1):e2142069. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.42069 (Reprinted) January 7, 2022 1/15 Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 01/17/2022 Abstract (continued)continued) [46.43%] vs 4 [7.02%]). One of the 56 participants (1.8%) in the therapeutic aquatic exercise group vs 2 of the 57 participants (3.5%) in the physical therapy modalities group experienced low back pain and other pains related to the intervention. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE The therapeutic aquatic exercise program led to greater alleviation in patients with chronic low back pain than physical therapy modalities and had a longterm effect up to 12 months. This finding may prompt clinicians to recommend therapeutic aquatic exercise to patients with chronic low back pain as part of treatment to improve their health through active exercise rather than relying on passive relaxation. TRIAL REGISTRATION Chinese Clinical Trial Registry: ChiCTR1800016396 JAMA Network Open. 2022;5(1):e2142069. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.42069 Introduction Low back pain is a high-incidence and high-burden condition.1 The incidence rate of low back pain in a lifetime is 84% and that of chronic low back pain is approximately 23%.2 A systematic analysis of global burden of disease showed that the number of years lived by patients with low back pain disability increased by 17.5% between 2007 and 2017.3 In the US, the annual total direct expenses for each patient with chronic low back pain reached $8386.4 Clinical practice guidelines recommend therapeutic exercise and physical therapy modalities for low back pain.5-7 Therapeutic exercise and physical therapy modalities can relieve pain intensity and alleviate back disability for patients with low back pain.8-12 Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and infrared ray thermal therapy are common modalities that are frequently used for treatment of chronic low back pain.13,14 Among the numerous therapeutic exercises available, therapeutic aquatic exercise is often prescribed by physicians for chronic low back pain, and it is becoming increasingly popular for treatment of chronic low back pain.15,16 Therapeutic aquatic exercise refers to water-based treatments or exercise. Water is an ideal environment for conducting an exercise program given its various properties, including buoyancy pressure, density, thermal capacity, and conductivity.17-22 Two systematic reviews suggested that therapeutic aquatic exercise can reduce pain intensity and improve function in patients with chronic low back pain.23,24 However, to our knowledge, evidence of the long-term benefits of therapeutic aquatic exercise in patients with chronic low back pain does not exist, and no study has compared the efficacy of therapeutic aquatic exercise and physical therapy modalities for chronic low back pain. Thus, we conducted a single-blind randomized clinical trial to compare the effects of therapeutic aquatic exercise with physical therapy modalities in patients with chronic low back pain over a 12-month follow-up period.