Subchondral Bone Plate Sclerosis During Late Osteoarthritis is Mediated by Loading-Induced Decrease in Sclerostin Amount
X. Ma,H. Jia,W. Tong,Z. Yang,Z. Sun,A. Chandra,L. Han,K. Zhang,J-C Wang,M. Enomoto-Iwamoto,L. Qin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joca.2017.02.500
IF: 7.507
2017-01-01
Osteoarthritis and Cartilage
Abstract:Purpose: Subchondral sclerosis is a hallmark of late OA and previous studies attribute it to a high bone turnover. In late stage disease, the subchondral bone plate (SBP) thickens, but subchondral trabecular bone undergoes bone loss. The exact mechanism is still largely unknown. Using a unique genetic mouse model that we recently established for OA study and a computational finite elemental analysis (FEA), we discovered a novel mechanical and cellular mechanism to explain how cartilage depletion causes local subchondral sclerosis. Methods: All animal work was approved by IACUC at the University of Pennsylvania. Animals and surgery- Cartilage-specific Egfr CKO (Col2-Cre EgfrWa5/f) mice and their Wa5 (EgfrWa5/f) and wild-type (WT, Col2-Cre Egfrf/+ and Egfrf/+) siblings were generated by breeding Col2a1-Cre, EgfrWa5/+, and Egfrf/f mice as described previously. EgfrWa5 codes for a kinase-dead, dominant negative receptor. To induce OA, male mice at 3 months of age were subjected to destabilization of the medial meniscus (DMM) surgery at the right knees and sham surgery at the left knees. Another OA mouse model was DMM and hemisectomy of the meniscus (DMMH) surgery on the right knees of WT mice. μCT- Distal femurs and proximal tibiae from mouse knee joints harvested after surgery were scanned by μCT 35 (Scanco Medical AG) at a resolution of 6 μm to calculate trabecular bone structural parameters. Histology and immunohistochemistry (IHC)- A serial of 6 μm-thick sagittal paraffin sections were cut across the entire joint followed by histology and IHC staining. FEA analysis- We constructed three knee models (Sham, early OA, and late OA) with effective modulus values obtained from nanoindentation tests for FEA using ANSYS160 by PLANE182 under axisymmetrical conditions. The top surface of femur was loaded with 1x104 Pa to simulate loading on mouse knee joints, while the bottom surface of tibia was fixed. Statistics- Data are expressed as means±SEM and analyzed by Student’s t-test. Results: At 2–3 months after DMM, while WT and Wa5 mice developed mild to moderate OA with no changes in the SBP, Egfr CKO mice exhibited the most severe OA with a complete loss of articular cartilage layer at the medial site (Fig. 1A) and mild cartilage degeneration at the lateral site. Interestingly, these mice had a substantial 2.0-fold thickening in SBP restricted only at the medial site (Fig. 1B), implicating that this localized SBP response is likely due to the alteration of overlaying articular cartilage. IHC revealed a 6.6-fold increase in the number of osteoblasts lining the SBP at the medial site (Fig. 1C). This enhanced bone formation was accompanied by increased length of blood vessels aligning SBP surface to support new bone formation. Wnts are potent signals for osteoblastic bone formation. Strikingly, staining of Sclerostin, a Wnt antagonist, in osteocytic cell bodies and dendritic processes, was remarkably attenuated in SBP at the medial site of CKO DMM joint (Fig. 1D). The amount of Sclerostin at the lateral site was similar to those at sham sites of three types of mice, as well as those at WT and Wa5 DMM sites. Aged Egfr CKO mice developed spontaneous OA at both medial and lateral sites, resulting in a similar level of SBP sclerosis across the entire knee (Fig. 2A, B). Interestingly, this was also accompanied by an elevation of osteoblasts at the bone marrow site of SBP (Fig. 2C) and a drastic reduction of osteocytic Sclerostin within SBP (Fig. 2D). Diminished Sclerostin amount at late OA is not limited to CKO mice only. At 16 weeks post DMMH, WT joints developed late OA symptoms at medial site. Similarly, DMMH knees had a significant decrease of sclerostin within SBP only at medial site but not at lateral site (Fig. 3). Mechanical loading is a major regulator of Sclerostin in the cortical bone. Using computational FEA to simulate mouse OA knees, we demonstrated that the highest focal stress on SBP at late OA stage (without cartilage) drastically increased to 14.6-fold of early OA joints (with cartilage), indicating that SBP at late OA experiences very high mechanical stress. Conclusions: :Our data demonstrated that increased mechanical loading on SBP after cartilage depletion at late OA attenuates osteocytic Sclerostin amount within SBP, resulting in increased bone formation at the bone marrow site of SBP and subsequent SBP sclerosis.Fig. 2. SBP sclerosis in aging Egfr CKO knees are caused by increased bone formation along SBP surface and suppressed Sclerostin expression in SBP. (A) Safranin O staining of femoral epiphyseal region in 12-month-old WT, Wa5, and CKO mice. Dashed lines: SBP. (B) μCT images of femoral epiphyseal region. Red arrows point to thickened SBP in CKO joints. (C) IHC of osteocalcin to identify osteoblasts (red arrowheads) beneath SBP. (D) IHC of Sclerostin in SBP. n=4/genotype.View Large Image Figure ViewerDownload Hi-res image Download (PPT)Fig. 3. Late OA symptoms after DMMH include thickened SBP and its associated reduction in osteocytic sclerostin amount. H&E staining (A,D) showed obvious SBP thickening (depicted by red lines) at the medial site (M) only. Sclerostin staining (B,C,E,F) on neighboring sections revealed reduced staining in medial site of DMMH knees (E). Black squares in A and D depict the corresponding areas for B,C,E,F. n=3 mice.View Large Image Figure ViewerDownload Hi-res image Download (PPT)