Strategies to Improve Emergency Transitions from Long-Term Care Facilities: A Scoping Review

Kaitlyn Tate,Greta Cummings,Frode Jacobsen,Gayle Halas,Graziella Van den Bergh,Rashmi Devkota,Shovana Shrestha,Malcolm Doupe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/geront/gnae036

2024-04-25

The Gerontologist

Abstract:Abstract Background and Objectives Older adults residing in residential aged care facilities (RACFs) often experience sub-standard transitions to emergency departments (EDs) through rationed and delayed ED care. We aimed to identify research describing interventions to improve transitions from RACFs to EDs. Research Design and Methods In our scoping review, we included English language articles that 1) examined an intervention to improve transitions from RACF to EDs, and 2) focused on older adults (>65 years). We employed content analysis. Dy et al.’s Care Transitions Framework was used to assess the contextualization of interventions and measurement of implementation success. Results Interventions in 28 studies included: geriatric assessment or outreach services (n=7), standardized documentation forms (n=6), models of care to improve transitions from RACFs to EDs (n=6), telehealth services (n=3), nurse-led care coordination programs (n=2), acute-care geriatric departments (n=2), an extended paramedicine program (n=1), and a web-based referral system (n=1). Many studies (n=17) did not define what ‘improvement’ entailed and instead assessed documentation strategies and distal outcomes (e.g., hospital admission rates, length of stay). Few authors reported how they contextualized interventions to align with care environments and/or evaluated implementation success. Few studies included clinician perspectives and no study examined resident or family/friend caregiver reported outcomes. Discussion and Implications Mixed or non-significant results prevent us from recommending (or discouraging) any interventions. Given the complexity of these transitions and the need to create sustainable improvement strategies, future research should describe strategies used to embed innovations in care contexts and to measure both implementation and intervention success.

geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to improve the referral process from Residential Aged Care Facilities (RACFs) to Emergency Departments (EDs). Specifically, the research aims to identify and describe the interventions used to improve these referral processes, and to evaluate the implementation strategies of these interventions and their effectiveness. The following are the main objectives of this paper:

1. **Identify and describe interventions**:
- Identify and describe various interventions or strategies used to improve the referral process from long - term care facilities to emergency departments.

2. **Describe implementation strategies**:
- Describe how researchers embed these interventions into the local care environment to ensure their effective implementation.

3. **Evaluate intervention and implementation effectiveness**:
- Identify methods used to evaluate the intervention measures and implementation effectiveness, including how to measure the success of these interventions.

### Background and Significance

With the growth of the elderly population, more and more elderly patients need to be referred between long - term care facilities and emergency departments. However, there are many challenges in these referral processes, such as coordinating professionals in different medical institutions, standardized and insufficient documentation, communication barriers, etc. These problems lead to poor medical outcomes, such as functional decline, dehydration, infection, confusion, and loss of personal assistive devices.

Therefore, through a systematic review, this paper summarizes the existing literature on improving the referral process from long - term care facilities to emergency departments, in order to provide guidance for future research and practice.

### Method

The study adopted a scoping review method, included studies in the English literature involving the elderly population aged 65 and above, and used the "Nursing Transition Framework" proposed by Dy et al. to evaluate the contextualization of interventions and the success of implementation. The research team also used the PRISMA - ScR guidelines for systematic literature screening and data extraction.

### Results

A total of 28 studies were included in the research, covering a variety of interventions, including geriatric assessment or outreach services, standardized documentation forms, improved care models, telemedicine services, nurse - led care coordination plans, etc. However, many studies failed to clearly define the meaning of "improvement", but mainly evaluated documentation strategies and distal outcomes (such as hospitalization rate, length of hospital stay). In addition, few studies considered the evaluation of the contextualization of interventions and the success of implementation.

### Discussion and Implications

Due to the complexity and non - significance of the results, the study cannot recommend or not recommend any specific intervention. In order to create sustainable improvement strategies, future research should describe in more detail how to embed innovation into the care environment, and simultaneously evaluate the success of interventions and implementation.

In conclusion, this paper emphasizes the necessity of evaluating the effectiveness of interventions and the success of implementation in a complex medical environment, and calls for future research to more clearly define the concept of "improvement" and specify in detail the design and contextualization process of interventions.