Theoretical, and epistemological challenges in scientific investigations of complex emotional states in animals

Yury V M Lages,Daniel C Mograbi,Thomas E Krahe,J Landeira-Fernandez
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.concog.2020.103003
Abstract:This review brings to light critical epistemological and theoretical considerations when studying complex emotional states in animals. We discuss anthropomorphic and Umwelt perspectives of nonhuman animals and the ways in which distinct theories of consciousness and neural processing may restrict the potential for the development of knowledge on the topic. Within the same line of argumentation, we consider influences of the debate between monism and dualism and psychology's behaviorism and cognitive theories. Finally, we contrast the affective consciousness, higher-order emotional consciousness, and constructed emotion theories to further our understanding of complex emotional states in animals.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?