Abstract:Despite the high prevalence and public health impact of refractive errors, the mechanisms responsible for ametropias are poorly understood. Much evidence now supports the concept that the retina is central to the mechanism(s) regulating emmetropization and underlying refractive errors. Using a variety of pharmacologic methods and well-defined experimental eye growth models in laboratory animals, many retinal neurotransmitters and neuromodulators have been implicated in this process. Nonetheless, an accepted framework for understanding the molecular and/or cellular pathways that govern postnatal eye development is lacking. Here, we review two extensively studied signaling pathways whose general roles in refractive development are supported by both experimental and clinical data: acetylcholine signaling through muscarinic and/or nicotinic acetylcholine receptors and retinal dopamine pharmacology. The muscarinic acetylcholine receptor antagonist atropine was first studied as an anti-myopia drug some two centuries ago, and much subsequent work has continued to connect muscarinic receptors to eye growth regulation. Recent research implicates a potential role of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors; and the refractive effects in population surveys of passive exposure to cigarette smoke, of which nicotine is a constituent, support clinical relevance. Reviewed here, many puzzling results inhibit formulating a mechanistic framework that explains acetylcholine's role in refractive development. How cholinergic receptor mechanisms might be used to develop acceptable approaches to normalize refractive development remains a challenge. Retinal dopamine signaling not only has a putative role in refractive development, its upregulation by light comprises an important component of the retinal clock network and contributes to the regulation of retinal circadian physiology. During postnatal development, the ocular dimensions undergo circadian and/or diurnal fluctuations in magnitude; these rhythms shift in eyes developing experimental ametropia. Long-standing clinical ideas about myopia in particular have postulated a role for ambient lighting, although molecular or cellular mechanisms for these speculations have remained obscure. Experimental myopia induced by the wearing of a concave spectacle lens alters the retinal expression of a significant proportion of intrinsic circadian clock genes, as well as genes encoding a melatonin receptor and the photopigment melanopsin. Together this evidence suggests a hypothesis that the retinal clock and intrinsic retinal circadian rhythms may be fundamental to the mechanism(s) regulating refractive development, and that disruptions in circadian signals may produce refractive errors. Here we review the potential role of biological rhythms in refractive development. While much future research is needed, this hypothesis could unify many of the disparate clinical and laboratory observations addressing the pathogenesis of refractive errors.

Elevated Melatonin Levels Found in Young Myopic Adults Are Not Attributable to a Shift in Circadian Phase

Late Bedtime and Altered Diurnal Axial Length Rhythms of the Eye

Myopia, Melatonin and Conjunctival Ultraviolet Autofluorescence: A Comparative Cross-sectional Study in Indian Myopes

Dim Light Exposure and Myopia in Children

Pharmacology of myopia and potential role for intrinsic retinal circadian rhythms

Blood levels of vitamin D in teens and young adults with myopia

The Timing of the Melatonin Onset and Phase Angle to Sleep Onset in Older Adults after Uncontrolled vs. Controlled Lighting Conditions

The Impact of Pupil Constriction on the Relationship Between Melanopic EDI and Melatonin Suppression in Young Adult Males

Axial growth and refractive change in white European children and young adults: predictive factors for myopia

Altered ocular parameters from circadian clock gene disruptions

Subclinical Decrease in Central Inner Retinal Activity Is Associated With Myopia Development in Children

Melatonin suppression by light involves different retinal photoreceptors in young and older adults

Structural, blood flow and functional changes in the macular area and the expression of aqueous humor factors in myopia

Assessment of daily light and ultraviolet exposure in young adults

Objectively Measured Light Exposure in Emmetropic and Myopic Adults

Ambient Light Regulates Retinal Dopamine Signaling and Myopia Susceptibility

Indoor and outdoor human behavior and myopia: an objective and dynamic study

Quantifying light exposure patterns in young adult students

Light levels, refractive development, and myopia--a speculative review

Association of sleep timings, duration, consistency, and chronotype with premyopia and myopia among Indian children

Diurnal retinal and choroidal gene expression patterns support a role for circadian biology in myopia pathogenesis