Speaking Compassionately with Seriously Ill Chinese Immigrants and Their Caregivers (仁医仁语) (RP120)
Zhimeng Jia,Allison M. Kurahashi,Ramona Mahtani,Irene Yeh,Richard E. Leiter,Kiern L. Quinn,Leah Steinberg,Jeff Myers,Justin J. Sanders,Robert Gramling,James A. Tulsky,Russell Goldman,Rashmi K. Sharma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2024.02.470
IF: 5.576
2024-04-19
Journal of Pain and Symptom Management
Abstract:Outcomes 1. Identify hidden costs to implementing theory-driven, culturally safe and linguistically aligned palliative care research with one immigrant Asian sub-population. 2. Recognize perceived role(s) and lived experiences of specialist PC among Chinese immigrant inpatients and their caregivers. Key Message Inpatient specialist palliative care clinicians may enhance Chinese families' serious illness experience by enacting therapeutic presence, balancing competing priorities, and pacing time-based health information. Further research is needed to triangulate Chinese families' palliative care experiences across clinical contexts and to elucidate clinician behaviors that promotes shared illness understanding. Importance Ethnically Chinese adults in North America frequently experience culturally disrespectful care at the end-of-life. Understanding Chinese patients' and their caregivers' lived palliative care (PC) experiences may uncover modifiable factors and clinician practices that promote health equity. Objective(s) Examine the perceived role(s) and lived experiences of specialist PC among Chinese immigrant inpatients and their caregivers. Scientific Methods Utilized From September 2022 to August 2023, we consecutively approached (n=21) and recruited (n=15, 71.4%) Chinese immigrant inpatients and their caregivers (n=14) referred to PC at one Canadian academic teaching hospital. Informed by Tan's Culturally Appropriateness in Health Communication framework, we collected participant self-reported questionnaires on sociodemographics, acculturation level (single item Suinn-Lew Asian Self-Identity Acculturation) and perceived clinician empathy (Consultation and Relational Empathy measure). We also conducted in-depth, post-consultation interviews (n=10) in Mandarin and/or English, which were recorded, transcribed, translated, and thematically analyzed. Results Patients were older-aged (73.5±16.2 years), 8/15 female, 9/15 college-educated, 10/15 non-religious, 14/15 diagnosed with cancer, and had low acculturation (mean=1.8±0.9/5.0), and Caregivers were middle-aged (50.6±15.5 years), 11/14 children, 8/14 female, 12/14 college-educated, 10/14 non-religious, and had moderate acculturation (mean=2.5±1.2/5.0). Most families (11/15) rated "very good" or "excellent" on all domains of the clinician empathy measure. We identified four themes from the post-consultation interviews: families arrive at PC with historical trauma that underscore distrust; PC ameliorates abandonment through an accompanying presence; PC eases relational suffering by brokering competing priorities between patients/caregivers/healthcare system; and PC alleviates temporal dissonance by gently pacing illness understanding discussions. Conclusion(s) Inpatient specialist palliative care consultants may enhance Chinese families' serious illness experience by enacting therapeutic presence, balancing competing priorities, and pacing time-based health information. Impact Further research is needed to triangulate Chinese families' palliative care experiences across clinical contexts and to elucidate clinician behaviors that promotes shared illness understanding. Keywords Cultural diversity/Communication and prognostication
medicine, general & internal,clinical neurology,health care sciences & services