Agricultural Extension for Adopting Technological Practices in Developing Countries: A Scoping Review of Barriers and Dimensions

Julián F. Becerra-Encinales,Paloma Bernal-Hernandez,Jorge A. Beltrán-Giraldo,Alexandre P. Cooman,Luis H. Reyes,Juan C. Cruz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16093555

IF: 3.9

2024-04-25

Sustainability

Abstract:This scoping review employed the PRISMA-ScR framework to dissect the complexities of technological extension in agriculture within developing nations, where varying socio-economic, cultural, and environmental facets deeply influence extension strategies. Our study aimed to identify and expand upon the existing knowledge of critical factors—both challenges and opportunities—that affect the efficacy of agricultural extension, with a focus on contextual variations. To achieve this, we conducted a comprehensive review of the relevant academic contributions from 2013 onwards. This included articles, reviews, conference proceedings, book chapters, and data papers. Our analysis focused on scrutinizing the interaction dynamics between extension personnel and farmers, the adaptation of technologies to local contexts, and the significance of cross-sector collaboration. Through bibliometric analysis, we provide a synthesis of 32 pertinent records. Our findings advocate for a paradigm shift from the traditional linear knowledge transfer to a more encompassing approach that values bidirectional communication, cultural awareness, and the active involvement of local farming communities. We argue for extension practices that are attuned to environmental dynamics, promote long-term economic sustainability, and are informed by theoretical perspectives that can refine the design of extension systems and models. Our review posits that the enhancement of sustainable agricultural technology adoption lies in a profound reform of extension systems. Such reform should focus on design and operational models that are more inclusive, adaptive, and acutely attuned to the complex realities of farmers in emerging economies. This integrative, systemic, and holistic approach proposes a framework to bolster agricultural sustainability and rural development.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the challenges and opportunities of adopting agricultural extension in developing countries through a scoping review. Specifically, the objectives of the paper include:

1. **Identifying Key Factors**: Determine the key factors affecting the effectiveness of agricultural extension, including challenges and opportunities, and analyze how these factors influence the effective adoption of agricultural technologies.
2. **Adaptive Strategies**: Emphasize that extension strategies need to be adjusted and adapted according to different socio-economic, cultural, and environmental contexts.
3. **Two-Way Communication and Cultural Awareness**: Advocate for a shift from the traditional one-way knowledge transfer model to a more inclusive two-way communication model, emphasizing cultural awareness and active participation of farming communities.
4. **Environmental Dynamics and Economic Sustainability**: Propose that extension practices should adapt to environmental changes, promote long-term economic sustainability, and improve the design of extension systems based on theoretical perspectives.

Through a comprehensive analysis of relevant literature, the paper reveals the specific application of agricultural extension in developing countries and proposes reform suggestions to establish a more inclusive, adaptive, and deeply understanding extension system that meets the real needs of farmers. This comprehensive, systematic, and thorough approach aims to enhance the adoption of sustainable agricultural technologies, thereby promoting agricultural sustainability and rural development.