Board Social Independence and CEO Turnover:Based on Research of Illegal Listed Company
Weian LI,Xiaolin LI,Yaowei ZHANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2017.02.008
2017-01-01
Journal of Management Science
Abstract:It is one of the most important decisions of the board of directors to change CEO timely and effectively when the listed company acts in violation of regulations. Board of directors performs as an important institution for supervision and decision-making of listed companies, and its independence is crucial. Board independence is the soul of corporate governance. Previous researches on board independence focus on the form of independence, ignoring the possible influence of other social factors on the functions of board of directors, such as the informal relationship and the fit degree of demographic characteristics between board members and CEO. Therefore, it is necessary to further explore the board social independence.From the perspective of the effectiveness of board supervision function, and using the social network theory and social identity theory, we innovatively construct the index of board social independence, which consists of both cognitive independence and relational independence. Taking A-share listed companies with CEO turnover during 2011-2014 and their paired firms as samples, using the probit model to empirically study the effect of board social independence on the CEO turnover when the companies act in violation especially under different circumstances.Study found that: first, the higher the board social independence is, the higher possibility of the illegal company′s CEO will be changed. The high fit degree formed between board members and CEO due to their close relationship and similar demographic characteristics, makes the board of directors can not objectively and impartially judge and supervise the performance of CEO; second, the functioning of board social independence is related to company′s ownership and performance, and the moderating effect of board social independence is more significant in private enterprises and companies with bad performance; last but not the least, external governance mechanism such as good institutional environment can play a security role on the functioning of board social independence, and the board social independence will affect the illegal listed company′s CEO turnover only in the case of better external governance.As an extension of the study of independence, board social independence has great theoretical and practical significance. The results show that promoting the effectiveness of corporate governance is not only to maintain the form of board independence, but also to enhance the board social independence. We need to strictly control the "related" CEO and the"similar" CEO, create an independent external environment for corporate governance, and have the board of directors to play better role of supervision.