Just Compensation: Paying Research Subjects Relative to the Risks They Bear

J. Menikoff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1162/152651601300169121

2001-02-01

Abstract:and may be susceptible to undue Žnancial inuences. For example, it makes sense to not pay prisoners any more money for research participation than they would earn for any other work they do in prison, because this would be a potentially undue inducement. Finally, in some subject populations Žnancial rewards for participation may be entirely inappropriate, because the money could cause more harm than good. For example, I think there is no good reason to pay money to a child who is too young to understand the concept of money or make good use of the money. In this situation the child is not likely to beneŽt from the money, but his or her parent or guardian could beneŽt from the money. Parents or guardians may therefore be tempted to enroll their child in the study to earn money. The same reasoning would apply to paying a profoundly retarded adult to participate in the study. If the adult cannot understand the concept of money or make good use of it, then giving that adult money for his or her participation may cause more harm than good. n