Abstract:Abstract Artificial intelligence is already all around us, and its usage will only increase. Knowing its capabilities is critical. A facial recognition system (FRS) is a tool for law enforcement during suspect searches and when presenting photos to eyewitnesses for identification. However, there are no comparisons between eyewitness and FRS accuracy using video, so it is unknown whether FRS face matches are more accurate than eyewitness memory when identifying a perpetrator. Ours is the first application of artificial intelligence to an eyewitness experience, using a comparative psychology approach. As a first step to test system accuracy relative to eyewitness accuracy, participants and an open-source FRS (FaceNet) attempted perpetrator identification/match from lineup photos (target-present, target-absent) after exposure to real crime videos with varied clarity and perpetrator race. FRS used video probe images of each perpetrator to achieve similarity ratings for each corresponding lineup member. Using receiver operating characteristic analysis to measure discriminability, FRS performance was superior to eyewitness performance, regardless of video clarity or perpetrator race. Video clarity impacted participant performance, with the unclear videos yielding lower performance than the clear videos. Using confidence-accuracy characteristic analysis to measure reliability (i.e., the likelihood the identified suspect is the actual perpetrator), when the FRS identified faces with the highest similarity values, they were accurate. The results suggest FaceNet, or similarly performing systems, may supplement eyewitness memory for suspect searches and subsequent lineup construction and knowing the system’s strengths and weaknesses is critical.

Detecting Faces, Saving Lives

Global adoption of facial recognition technology with special reference to India—Present status and future recommendations

The Implications of Using Artificial Intelligence (AI) for Facial Analysis and Recognition

Facial Recognition: A cross-national Survey on Public Acceptance, Privacy, and Discrimination

Reading Face, Reading Health: Exploring Face Reading Technologies for Everyday Health

Using Facial Recognition Tools for Health Assessment

Responsible Facial Recognition and Beyond

Has Facial Recognition Technology Been Misused? A Public Perception Model of Facial Recognition Scenarios

Beyond surveillance: privacy, ethics, and regulations in face recognition technology

The Work to Make Facial Recognition Work

Seeing infrastructure: race, facial recognition and the politics of data

Smile, you are being identified! Risks and measures for the use of facial recognition in (semi-)public spaces

The ethical application of biometric facial recognition technology

RFace: Anti-Spoofing Facial Authentication Using COTS RFID

Facial Recognition Technology: is It Ready to Be Used in Public Health Surveillance?

Facial recognition technology: regulations, rights and the rule of law

Facial recognition technology in schools: critical questions and concerns

Application of artificial intelligence to eyewitness identification

(Do not) remember my face: uses of facial recognition technology in light of the general data protection regulation

Face Recognition: to Deploy or not to Deploy? A Framework for Assessing the Proportional Use of Face Recognition Systems in Real-World Scenarios

Saving Face: Investigating the Ethical Concerns of Facial Recognition Auditing