Abstract:The objective of this randomized controlled experiment was to evaluate the effect of reproductive management programs that prioritized artificial insemination (AI) at detected estrus (AIE) or timed AI (TAI) during the first lactation on the economic performance of dairy cows of different genomically enhanced predicted transmitting ability for fertility. Lactating primiparous Holstein cows from 6 commercial farms were stratified into high, medium, and low fertility groups based on a reproduction index value calculated from multiple genomically enhanced predicted transmitting abilities to predict the number of days to achieve pregnancy. Within herd and fertility group, cows were randomly assigned either to a program that prioritized AIE (P-AIE; n = 1,416) and used TAI for cows not AIE for all AI services or another that prioritized TAI and had an extended voluntary waiting period for first service and prioritized TAI for second and greater AI services (P-TAI; n = 1,338). Cash flow (CF) per cow accumulated for the experimental (first) and second calving interval (CIN) and cash flow per slot per 28 mo after calving in the experimental lactation were calculated. Market and rearing heifer cost values were used for estimating CF. For cows in the high fertility group, a positive effect of delayed pregnancy on milk income during the first lactation was observed (+$248 for P-TAI) but was insufficient to generate significant differences in CF between treatments mainly because of milk income compensation in the second lactation (+$125 for P-AIE) and minor reductions in reproductive cost and gains in calf value for the P-AIE treatment. In this regard, CF for 2 CIN was greater for the P-TAI treatment by $61 and $86 for market and rearing replacement heifer cost, respectively. Similarly, CF per slot was favorable to the P-TAI treatment but only by $13 and $47 for market and rearing replacement heifer cost, respectively. For cows in the low fertility group, CF was numerically in favor of the P-AIE treatment due to a pregnancy and herd exit dynamics that resulted in gains in milk income over feed cost during the first ($29) and second ($113) lactation. Differences in CF for the 2 CIN were $58 and $47 for market or rearing heifer value, respectively, and $77 and $19 for market and rearing heifer values, respectively for the slot analysis. Differences in CF between cows of different genetic merit for fertility were consistent across treatment and estimation method. Of note, cows in the low fertility group had greater CF than cows in the high fertility group in all comparisons, ranging from $198 per cow for 2 CIN to as much as $427 per slot. For the low fertility group, greater milk production contributed directly (milk income over feed cost) and indirectly (reduced culling) to increased CF. We concluded that genetic merit for fertility and CF are associated because cows of inferior genetic potential for fertility had greater CF than cows of superior genetic for fertility despite some increased costs and reduced revenues. Also, the magnitude of the CF differences observed for cows of different genetic merit for fertility managed with the P-AIE or P-TAI program may be valuable to commercial dairy farms but did not allow to conclusively support the choice of a type of reproductive management strategy for cows of different genetic merit for fertility.

Sire selection and genetic improvement of dairy cattle assuming pure market competition

A breeding index to rank beef bulls for use on dairy females to maximize profit

Invited review: selection on net merit to improve lifetime profit

Symposium review: Possibilities in an age of genomics: The future of selection indices

Economic impact of different strategies to use sex-sorted sperm for reproductive management in seasonal-calving, pasture-based dairy herds

An evaluation of alternative selection indexes for a non-linear profit trait approaching its economic optimum

Impact of Selection Index on the Rank of Chinese Holstein Bulls

Enhancing milk and fertility performances using selection index developed for Indian Murrah buffaloes

Index selection on seed traits under direct, cytoplasmic and maternal effects in multiple environments

Effect of reproductive management programs that prioritized artificial insemination at detected estrus or timed artificial insemination on the economic performance of primiparous Holstein cows of different genetic merit for fertility

Breeding objectives for pigs in Kenya. II: economic values incorporating risks in different smallholder production systems

Genetic evaluation of udder health traits in Spanish Holstein cows

Alternative Traits for Genetic Evaluation of Mastitis Based on Lifetime Merit

Genomic Evaluation for Two-Way Crossbred Performance in Cattle.

Genomic Analysis, Progress and Future Perspectives in Dairy Cattle Selection: A Review

EFFECTS OF BEEF SEMEN AND BEEF EMBRYO STRATEGIES ON PROFITABILITY: Economics of using beef semen and beef in vitro produced embryo transfer in Jersey herds

Effect of germplasm exchange strategies on genetic gain, homozygosity, and genetic diversity in dairy stud populations: A simulation study

Reviving the Desired Gains Index: An optimal solution for parent selection in public plant breeding programs

A bioeconomic model for comparing beef cattle genotypes at their optimal economic slaughter end point

Contribution of semen trait selection, artificial insemination technique, and semen dose to the profitability of pig production systems: A simulation study

Predictive Ability of Direct Genomic Values for Lifetime Net Merit of Holstein Sires Using Selected Subsets of Single Nucleotide Polymorphism Markers