Anne J. Maheux,Jean-Philippe Laurenceau,Savannah R. Roberts,Jacqueline Nesi,Laura Widman,Sophia Choukas-Bradley
Abstract:Online appearance preoccupation may put adolescents at risk of developing mental health challenges, perhaps especially during early-to-middle adolescence. A random intercept cross-lagged panel model assessed within-person associations between appearance-related social media consciousness and depressive symptoms over three time-points with three months between waves. The sample ( n = 1594) included U.S. adolescents aged 11–15 ( M age = 13; 47% girls, 46% boys, 7% another gender; 37% Latine, 33% White, 18% Black, 7% Asian). Within-person increases in appearance-related social media consciousness were associated with subsequent increases in depressive symptoms, but not vice versa. There was no evidence of gender differences and results were robust to controlling for both time on social media and offline self-objectification. Thus, online appearance concerns precede mental health challenges during early and middle adolescence.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to explore the longitudinal relationship between appearance - related social media consciousness (ASMC) and depressive symptoms among early - to - mid - adolescents (approximately 11 - 15 years old) on social media. Specifically, the researchers hope to evaluate the within - individual change relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms at three time points (once every three months) through the Random Intercept Cross - Lagged Panel Model (RICLPM). The main research questions include:
1. **Relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms**:
- Is there a relationship where an increase in ASMC leads to a subsequent increase in depressive symptoms?
- Conversely, is there a relationship where an increase in depressive symptoms leads to a subsequent increase in ASMC?
2. **Gender differences**:
- Are there differences between male and female adolescents in the relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms?
3. **Influence of control variables**:
- After controlling for social media use time and offline self - objectification, is the relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms still significant?
### Research background
With the popularization of social media, adolescents are increasingly showing and paying attention to their appearance on these platforms. This online appearance - related attention may have a negative impact on adolescents' mental health, especially in the early - to - mid - adolescent stage. Previous studies have shown that the relationship between social media use time and depressive symptoms is inconsistent, so more specific research on specific online behaviors and subjective cognitive experiences is required. In particular, highly visual social media platforms (such as Instagram, Snapchat, etc.) may exacerbate adolescents' appearance - related attention, thus affecting their mental health.
### Research methods
- **Sample**: 1,594 American adolescents, aged 11 to 15 years old, with an average age of 13 years old, of which 47% are girls, 46% are boys, and 7% are other genders.
- **Data collection**: Data were collected at three time points (October, January, March) during the 2020 - 2021 school year.
- **Measurement tools**:
- **ASMC**: A 13 - item scale was used to assess the degree of adolescents' attention to appearance on social media.
- **Depressive symptoms**: The 13 - item Short Mood and Feelings Questionnaire (SMFQ) was used to assess depressive symptoms in the past two weeks.
- **Control variables**: Including social media use time and self - objectification.
### Main findings
- **Relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms**:
- An increase in within - individual ASMC was significantly associated with a subsequent increase in depressive symptoms (b = 0.25, p = 0.002).
- Conversely, an increase in depressive symptoms was not significantly associated with a subsequent increase in ASMC (b = 0.10, p = 0.113).
- **Gender differences**:
- There were no significant differences between male and female adolescents in the relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms.
- **Influence of control variables**:
- After controlling for social media use time and self - objectification, the relationship between ASMC and depressive symptoms remained significant.
### Conclusion
This study found that in early - to - mid - adolescence, an increase in ASMC precedes an increase in depressive symptoms, and this relationship does not differ significantly between male and female adolescents. In addition, after controlling for social media use time and self - objectification, this relationship still holds. These results emphasize the important impact of online appearance - related attention on adolescents' mental health, suggesting that parents and educators should pay attention to adolescents' behaviors on social media to prevent potential mental health problems.