Virtual Reality and Serious Videogame-Based Instruments for Assessing Spatial Navigation in Alzheimer's Disease: A Systematic Review of Psychometric Properties

Juan Pablo Sánchez-Escudero,Ana María Galvis-Herrera,David Sánchez-Trujillo,Laura Cristina Torres-López,Cole J. Kennedy,Daniel Camilo Aguirre-Acevedo,Mauricio A. Garcia-Barrera,Natalia Trujillo,Kennedy, Cole J.,Garcia-Barrera, Mauricio A.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11065-024-09633-7
2024-02-27
Neuropsychology Review
Abstract:Over the past decade, research using virtual reality and serious game-based instruments for assessing spatial navigation and spatial memory in at-risk and AD populations has risen. We systematically reviewed the literature since 2012 to identify and evaluate the methodological quality and risk of bias in the analyses of the psychometric properties of VRSG-based instruments. The search was conducted primarily in July–December 2022 and updated in November 2023 in eight major databases. The quality of instrument development and study design were analyzed in all studies. Measurement properties were defined and analyzed according to COSMIN guidelines. A total of 1078 unique records were screened, and following selection criteria, thirty-seven studies were analyzed. From these studies, 30 instruments were identified. Construct and criterion validity were the most reported measurement properties, while structural validity and internal consistency evidence were the least reported. Nineteen studies were deemed very good in construct validity, whereas 11 studies reporting diagnostic accuracy were deemed very good in quality. Limitations regarding theoretical framework and research design requirements were found in most of the studies. VRSG-based instruments are valuable additions to the current diagnostic toolkit for AD. Further research is required to establish the psychometric performance and clinical utility of VRSG-based instruments, particularly the instrument development, content validity, and diagnostic accuracy for preclinical AD screening scenarios. This review provides a straightforward synthesis of the state of the art of VRSG-based instruments and suggests future directions for research.
psychology, clinical,neurosciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the methodological quality and risk of bias in the psychometric properties of virtual reality and serious games (VRSG) - based tools for assessing spatial navigation and spatial memory in the Alzheimer's disease (AD) population. Specifically, this systematic review aims to: 1. **Identify and describe existing VRSG tools**: These tools are used to assess the spatial navigation and spatial memory abilities of people in the pre - clinical, mild cognitive impairment (MCI), and AD dementia stages of AD. 2. **Evaluate the quality of research methods**: Conduct a quality assessment of the research methods of these tools to determine their reliability and validity. 3. **Analyze the risk of psychometric properties**: Use the COSMIN guidelines to assess the risk of bias in the analysis of the psychometric properties (such as construct validity, internal consistency, criterion validity, and construct validity) of these tools. Through these objectives, this review aims to provide detailed information on the quality of existing evidence, help researchers and clinical neuropsychologists understand the latest progress of current VRSG tools in assessing spatial navigation and spatial memory in AD - at - risk populations, and provide suggestions for future research directions.