Abstract:In the current digital era, crucial questions include whether and how nondemocratic regimes retain information control in the face of proliferating new communication technologies. The scholarship has long cited China as a prime example of how authoritarian regimes implement internet censorship. Echoing emergent studies that have called attention to the highly fragmented nature of China's censorship agencies, which operate at different government levels, this research addresses local censorship agencies and their practices. Combining participatory observations and in-depth interviews conducted in a district in H City, one of China's digital economy hubs, this research explores how the local censorship regime deploys soft forms of maintaining control over information. Based on an institutional approach, the findings show that the local censorship regime has adopted proactive strategies to build a reciprocal relationship with local news start-ups, forming a variant of 'contingent symbiosis'. The local censorship regime uses policy and economic stimulus to co-opt news start-ups, inducing them to distance themselves from politically sensitive issues and local negative news and boost local propaganda agendas. These internet organisations have attempted to sustain positive relationships with the local censorship regime to acquire government resources and patronage, which would ensure their stable operation and survival under stiff competition in a precarious institutional environment. This research further explains the conditions of fragmented governance and platformisation under which this contingent symbiosis forms and the routinised practices that sustain it. This relational governance is covert and brings new challenges to the free flow of information.

Participatory censorship: How online fandom community facilitates authoritarian rule

Anti-system Contentions and Authoritarian Response in China: Evolution and Mechanisms

How We Express Ourselves Freely: Censorship, Self-censorship, and Anti-censorship on a Chinese Social Media

Blurring the Lines: Rethinking Censorship under Autocracy

Reverse-engineering censorship in China: Randomized experimentation and participant observation

Let's report our rivals: how Chinese fandoms game content moderation to restrain opposing voices

Who Not What: The Logic of China's Information Control Strategy

Scaling Authoritarian Information Control: How China Adjusts the Level of Online Censorship

Implicit And Explicit Control: Modeling The Effect Of Internet Censorship On Political Protest In China

Fandom and coercive empowerment: the commissioned production of Chinese online literature

Unveiling the Dynamics of Censorship, COVID-19 Regulations, and Protest: An Empirical Study of Chinese Subreddit r/china_irl

Contingent Symbiosis: News Start-Ups and Local Cyberspace Administration in Contemporary China

THE DILEMMA OF CRITICISM: DISENTANGLING THE DETERMINANTS OF MEDIA CENSORSHIP IN CHINA

Contriving the Future by Tampering with the Past: A Deferral Tactic in Chinese Internet Censorship

Which Social Media Facilitate Online Public Opinion in China?

The Media and Urban Contention in China: a Co-Empowerment Model

Attraction or Distraction? Impacts of Pro-regime Social Media Comments on Chinese Netizens

Internet and Self-Regulation in China: the Cultural Logic of Controlled Commodification

A Study of LGBTQ+ Empowerment and Normative Dialogue in Chinese Social Media Platforms

Linguistic Fingerprints of Internet Censorship: the Case of SinaWeibo

Governing Generation Z in China: Bilibili, bidirectional mediation, and online community governance