Abstract:Background Avian brood parasites and their hosts are involved in complex offence-defense coevolutionary arms races. The most common pair of reciprocal adaptations in these systems is egg discrimination by hosts and egg mimicry by parasites. As mimicry improves, more advanced host adaptations evolve such as decreased intra- and increased interclutch variation in egg appearance to facilitate detection of parasitic eggs. As interclutch variation increases, parasites able to choose hosts matching best their own egg phenotype should be selected, but this requires that parasites know their own egg phenotype and select host nests correspondingly. Methodology/Principal Findings We compared egg mimicry of common cuckoo Cuculus canorus eggs in naturally parasitized marsh warbler Acrocephalus palustris nests and their nearest unparasitized conspecific neighbors having similar laying dates and nest-site characteristics. Modeling of avian vision and image analyses revealed no evidence that cuckoos parasitize nests where their eggs better match the host eggs. Cuckoo eggs were as good mimics, in terms of background and spot color, background luminance, spotting pattern and egg size, of host eggs in the nests actually exploited as those in the neighboring unparasitized nests. Conclusions/Significance We reviewed the evidence for brood parasites selecting better-matching host egg phenotypes from several relevant studies and argue that such selection probably cannot exist in host-parasite systems where host interclutch variation is continuous and overall low or moderate. To date there is also no evidence that parasites prefer certain egg phenotypes in systems where it should be most advantageous, i.e., when both hosts and parasites lay polymorphic eggs. Hence, the existence of an ability to select host nests to maximize mimicry by brood parasites appears unlikely, but this possibility should be further explored in cuckoo-host systems where the host has evolved discrete egg phenotypes.

Extreme offspring ornamentation in American coots is favored by selection within families, not benefits to conspecific brood parasites

Nestling size and ornamentation interact to shape early development in house sparrow families

The bright incubate at night: sexual dichromatism and adaptive incubation division in an open-nesting shorebird

Plumage and eggshell colouration covary with the level of sex-specific parental contributions to nest building in birds

Brighter yellow blue tits make better parents

Parental kinship coefficient but not paternal coloration predicts early offspring growth in lake char

Coevolution in Action: Disruptive Selection on Egg Colour in an Avian Brood Parasite and Its Host.

Dark nests and conspicuousness in color patterns of nestlings of altricial birds

Egg Color Variation, but Not Egg Rejection Behavior, Changes in a Cuckoo Host Breeding in the Absence of Brood Parasitism

Fear, food and sexual ornamentation: plasticity of colour development in Trinidadian guppies

Experimental Evidence That Cuckoos Choose Host Nests Following an Egg Matching Strategy

Visual modeling shows that avian host parents use multiple visual cues in rejecting parasitic eggs

Carotenoid skin ornaments as flexible indicators of male foraging behavior in a marine predator: Variation among Mexican colonies of brown booby (Sula leucogaster)

Plaintive Cuckoos Do Not Select Tailorbird Hosts That Match the Phenotypes of Their Own Eggs

Nestling colouration is adjusted to parent visual performance in altricial birds

Are Cuckoos Maximizing Egg Mimicry by Selecting Host Individuals with Better Matching Egg Phenotypes?

Parasitic begging calls of nestmate-evictor common cuckoos stimulate more parental provisions by red-winged blackbirds than calls of nest-sharing brown-headed cowbirds

Complex plumages spur rapid color diversification in kingfishers (Aves: Alcedinidae)

Nestling Recognition in Red-Rumped and Barn Swallows

Coevolution of costly mate choice and condition-dependent display of good genes

Selection and inheritance of sexually dimorphic juvenile plumage coloration