Moderating Effects of Dietary Restraint and Self-Compassion in an Expressive Writing Intervention in Southeast Asian Population
Dennis Relojo
2016-05-01
Abstract:Body dissatisfaction is prevalent among women in both Western and Asian societies and there are a host of studies (Anderson, Reilly, Gorrell, & Anderson, 2016; Bell, Donovan, & Ramme, 2016; Cano, Fernandez, Saenz, Moreno, & Leal, 2016) that implicate how this leads to eating disorders. Ironically, body dissatisfaction is also markedly common among individuals both men and women with normal weight, especially among females (Margolis & Orsillo, 2016), confirming the crucial role of self- perception. Being fairly ubiquitous among women,body dissatisfaction has been studied, and these studies point out that similar with popular expectation, there are more women than men who are trying to lose weight and do so at lower Body Mass Index (BMI) levels (Bish et al., 2005). Indeed, women are more susceptible to body dissatisfaction compared to men.Female adolescents are bombarded with thin-ideal images from the media, with music videos and magazines being the most popular sources of these images. A recent content analysis of ten women's magazines (Wasylkiw, Emms, Meuse, & Poirier, 2009) showed that 95 per cent of the models in fashion magazines were thin; in fitness magazines, 55 per cent were thin and 36 per cent were muscular, only six per cent of the models in both magazine types possess round body type. Furthermore, content analyses of images in women's magazines from 1959 to 1999 (Sypeck, Gray, & Ahrens, 2004) revealed that the models have become increasingly thinner over time. These findings validate the sociocultural perspective that mass media publicise a slender ideal which in turn elicits body dissatisfaction (Ata, Thompson, & Small, 2013).Over the past decades, an increasing discrepancy between body shapes portrayed as ideal in the media and actual body shapes found in the general population has been observed. Much of the studies in this area have been done on Western population, nevertheless, the problem also exists in the Philippines. For instance, it has been observed in the Philippines that the prevalence of overweight and obesity combined increased nearly six-fold from around 6 per cent in 1983 to 1984, to 35 per cent in 1998 to 1999 (Adair, 2004). More recently, it has been reported by Sy and colleagues (2008, as cited in Litonjua, 2014) that from 1993-2008, obesity among Filipinos continued to increase at about 3.4 per cent and climbing to 5.2 per cent. Additionally, cases of overweight rose from 15.2 per cent to 21.4 per cent in the same period.Expressive Writing as a ToolExpressive writing (EW) is a therapy introduced by Pennebaker and Beall in the late 1980's. Their pioneering work (Pennebaker & Beall, 1986) involved requesting participants to write about a "past trauma", as a way to convey their deepest feelings and thoughts. Control groups were instructed to write on neutral topics (e.g. What are their plans for the day?), without revealing their emotions or opinions. Both groups were requested to do this for 15 minutes per day for four consecutive days. Participants were further advised that should they run out of things to write, they should go back from the start and simply repeat themselves and to try to write a little differently.Since the introduction of EW, it has been used in a variety of ways to improve psychological well-being, ranging from improving the selfconcept of adolescents (Facchin, Margola, Molgora, & Revenson, 2013), to helping people with traumatic brain injury (Wheeler, Nickerson, Long, & Silver, 2013). Although it has been observed that EW may help improve body image perception (Lafont, 2011), there is a dearth of studies that examined its efficacy to address the negative effects of exposure to thinideal images.Media and Body DissatisfactionImages idealising thin bodies are known to increase the likelihood of body dissatisfaction among Asian adolescents (Chang et al., 2013). It has been known that media pressure and body dissatisfaction contributed to both restrained eating and unhealthy weight control behaviours. …
Medicine,Psychology