Predicting remission following CBT for childhood anxiety disorders: a machine learning approach
Lizel-Antoinette Bertie,Juan C. Quiroz,Shlomo Berkovsky,Kristian Arendt,Susan Bögels,Jonathan R. I. Coleman,Peter Cooper,Cathy Creswell,Thalia C. Eley,Catharina Hartman,Krister Fjermestadt,Tina In-Albon,Kristen Lavallee,Kathryn J. Lester,Heidi J. Lyneham,Carla E. Marin,Anna McKinnon,Lauren F. McLellan,Richard Meiser-Stedman,Maaike Nauta,Ronald M. Rapee,Silvia Schneider,Carolyn Schniering,Wendy K. Silverman,Mikael Thastum,Kerstin Thirlwall,Polly Waite,Gro Janne Wergeland,Viviana Wuthrich,Jennifer L. Hudson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0033291724002654
IF: 10.592
2024-12-18
Psychological Medicine
Abstract:Background The identification of predictors of treatment response is crucial for improving treatment outcome for children with anxiety disorders. Machine learning methods provide opportunities to identify combinations of factors that contribute to risk prediction models. Methods A machine learning approach was applied to predict anxiety disorder remission in a large sample of 2114 anxious youth (5–18 years). Potential predictors included demographic, clinical, parental, and treatment variables with data obtained pre-treatment, post-treatment, and at least one follow-up. Results All machine learning models performed similarly for remission outcomes, with AUC between 0.67 and 0.69. There was significant alignment between the factors that contributed to the models predicting two target outcomes: remission of all anxiety disorders and the primary anxiety disorder. Children who were older, had multiple anxiety disorders, comorbid depression, comorbid externalising disorders, received group treatment and therapy delivered by a more experienced therapist, and who had a parent with higher anxiety and depression symptoms, were more likely than other children to still meet criteria for anxiety disorders at the completion of therapy. In both models, the absence of a social anxiety disorder and being treated by a therapist with less experience contributed to the model predicting a higher likelihood of remission. Conclusions These findings underscore the utility of prediction models that may indicate which children are more likely to remit or are more at risk of non-remission following CBT for childhood anxiety.
psychiatry,psychology, clinical