Abstract:Background: Relatively little is known about the immediate and prospective neurodevelopmental impacts of joint exposure to multiple metals (i.e., metal mixtures) in early childhood. Objectives: To estimate associations of early childhood (∼3 years of age) blood metal concentrations with cognitive test scores at early and mid-childhood (∼8 years of age). Methods: We studied children from the Project Viva cohort. We measured erythrocyte concentrations of seven essential (Co, Cu, Mg, Mn, Mo, Se, and Zn) and eight non-essential metals (As, Ba, Cd, Cs, Hg, Pb, Sn, and Sr) in early childhood blood samples. Trained research assistants administered cognitive tests assessing vocabulary, visual-motor ability, memory, and general intelligence (standard deviations: ∼10 points), in early and mid-childhood. We employed multivariable linear regression to examine associations of individual metals with test scores adjusting for confounders, other concurrently measured metals, and first-trimester maternal blood metals. We also estimated joint associations and explored interaction between metals in mixture analyses. Results: We analyzed 349 children (median whole blood Pb ∼1 μg/dL). In cross-sectional analyses, each doubling of Pb was associated with lower visual-motor function (mean difference: -2.43 points, 95% confidence interval (CI): -4.01, -0.86) and receptive vocabulary, i.e., words understood (-1.45 points, 95% CI: -3.26, 0.36). Associations of Pb with mid-childhood cognition were weaker and less precise by comparison. Mg was positively associated with cognition in cross-sectional but not prospective analyses, and cross-sectional associations were attenuated in a sensitivity analysis removing adjustment for concurrent metals. We did not observe joint associations nor interactions. Discussion: In this cohort with low blood Pb levels, increased blood Pb was robustly associated with lower cognitive ability in cross-sectional analyses, even after adjustment for prenatal Pb exposure, and regardless of adjustment for metal co-exposures. However, associations with mid-childhood cognition were attenuated and imprecise, suggesting some buffering of Pb neurotoxicity in early life. What this study adds: Relatively few studies have comprehensively separated the effects of neurotoxic metals such as lead (Pb) from pre- and postnatal co-occurring metals, nor examined persistence of associations across childhood. In a cohort of middle-class children, we found higher early childhood (∼3 y) blood Pb was associated with lower scores on cognitive tests, independent of other metals and prenatal blood Pb. However, early childhood Pb was only weakly associated with cognition in mid-childhood (∼8 y). Our results suggest the effects of low-level Pb exposure may attenuate over time in some populations, implying the presence of factors that may buffer Pb neurotoxicity in early life.

Time-varying associations between prenatal metal mixtures and rapid visual processing in children

Cross-sectional and prospective associations of early childhood circulating metals with early and mid-childhood cognition in the Project Viva cohort

Prenatal exposure to metal mixtures and childhood temporal processing in the PROGRESS Birth Cohort Study: Modification by childhood obesity

Association of prenatal multiple metal exposures with child neurodevelopment at 3 years of age: A prospective birth cohort study

Association of both prenatal and early childhood multiple metals exposure with neurodevelopment in infant: A prospective cohort study

Associations between prenatal metal and metalloid mixtures in teeth and reductions in childhood lung function

Early postnatal and concurrent exposure to metals and neurobehavioral outcomes at 5 years: Associations with individual environmental exposures and mixtures

Prenatal metal mixture concentrations and reward motivation in children

Low Level Prenatal Exposure to a Mixture of Sr, Se and Mn and Neurocognitive Development of 2-Year-old Children.

Prenatal Metal Mixture Exposure and Birth Weight: A Two-Stage Analysis in Two Prospective Cohort Studies

Associations between maternal exposure to multiple metals and metalloids and blood pressure in preschool children: A mixture-based approach

107 Environmental Exposure to Metals Mixtures and the Outcome of Cognitive Function in Adolescents

Association between maternal metal exposure during early pregnancy and intelligence in children aged 3-6 years: Results from a Chinese birth cohort

Exposure to metal mixtures and young children’s growth and development: A biomonitoring-based study in Eastern China

Maternal exposure to metal mixtures during early pregnancy and fetal growth in the Jiangsu Birth Cohort, China

Prenatal metal mixtures and fetal size in mid-pregnancy in the MADRES study

Associations Between Prenatal Multiple Metal Exposure and Preterm Birth: Comparison of Four Statistical Models

Association Between Prenatal Exposure to Metal Mixtures and Early Childhood Allergic Diseases

Chemical mixture exposures during pregnancy and cognitive abilities in school-aged children

Effects of preterm birth and postnatal exposure to metal mixtures on neurodevelopment in children at 24 months of age

Perinatal and Childhood Exposure to Cadmium, Manganese, and Metal Mixtures and Effects on Cognition and Behavior: A Review of Recent Literature