Abstract:Background: Treating tibial non-unions efficiently presents a challenge for orthopaedic trauma surgeons. The established gold standard involves implanting autologous bone graft with adequate fixation, but the addition of biologicals according to the so-called diamond concept has become increasingly popular in the treatment of non-unions. Previous studies have indicated that polytherapy, which involves implanting mesenchymal stem cells, bioactive factors and osteoconductive scaffolds, can improve bone healing. This study aims to evaluate the efficacy of polytherapy compared with monotherapy in treating tibial non-unions of varying severity. Materials and methods: Data from consecutive tibial non-unions treated between November 2014 and July 2023 were retrospectively analysed. The Non Union Scoring System (NUSS) score before non-union surgery, and the Radiographic Union Score for Tibial fractures (RUST), scored at 1, 3, 6, 9, 12 and 18 months post-surgery, were recorded. Initially, a comparison was made between the polytherapy and monotherapy groups. Subsequently, patients receiving additional surgical non-union treatment were documented, and the frequency of these treatments was tallied for a subsequent per-treatment analysis. Results: A total of 34 patients were included and divided into a polytherapy group (n = 15) and a monotherapy group (n = 19). The polytherapy group demonstrated a higher NUSS score (44 (39, 52) versus 32 (29, 43), P = 0.019, z = -2.347) and a tendency towards a higher success rate (93% versus 68%, P = 0.104) compared with the monotherapy group. For the per-treatment analysis, 44 treatments were divided into the polytherapy per-treatment group (n = 20) and the monotherapy per-treatment group (n = 24). The polytherapy per-treatment group exhibited a higher NUSS score (48 (43, 60) versus 38 (30, 50), P = 0.030, z = -2.173) and a higher success rate (95% versus 58%, P = 0.006) than the monotherapy per-treatment group. Within the monotherapy per-treatment group, the NUSS score displayed excellent predictive performance (AUC = 0.9143). Setting the threshold value at 48, the sensitivity and specificity were 100.0% and 70.0%, respectively. Conclusions: Polytherapy is more effective than monotherapy for severe tibial non-unions, offering a higher success ratio. The NUSS score supports decision-making in treating tibial non-unions. Level of evidence: Level III.

The use of a gentamicin-coated titanium nail, combined with RIA system, in the management of non-unions of open tibial fractures: A single centre prospective study

Evaluation of the clinical use of the ETN PROtect® in non-union therapy

Gentamicincoated tibial nail is an effective prevention method for fracture-related infections in open tibial fractures

Effectiveness of antibiotic-coated intramedullary nails for open tibia fracture infection prevention. A systematic review and meta-analysis

Preliminary Outcomes of a Staged Percutaneous Retrograde Prefabricated Gentamicin-coated Intramedullary Nail to Manage Complications after Ankle Fusion through Tibial Bone Transport

Tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis through retrograde nailing for the treatment of juxtaarticular distal tibia aseptic non-unions: A retrospective study at a minimum follow-up of 4 years

Non-vascularized Fibular Autograft and Locking Plate: A Solution to the Resistant Nonunion of a Tibial Metaphyseal Fracture

Reconstruction of bone defects around the ankle with retrograde gentamicin-coated tibial intramedullary nail (ETN PROtect™) for tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis: a case series

Treatment of Diaphyseal Tibial Non-unions After Open Fracture: A Retrospective Observational Study on Characteristics and Outcomes

Management of Non-union Distal Femur Fractures With Augmentation Nail Plate Construct

Subtrochanteric fracture non-unions with implant failure managed with the "Diamond" concept

Treatment of Infected Tibia Non-union Using a Novel Solid Intramedullary Nail Custom-Made for Antibiotic-Impregnated Cement Coating

Nonunion of the distal one-fourth of the tibia treated by retrograde tibial intramedullary nail

Effectiveness of exchange K-nail and augmented plating in aseptic femoral diaphyseal non-union

Polytherapy versus monotherapy in the treatment of tibial non-unions: a retrospective study

The Reamer-Irrigator-Aspirator (RIA) System for the treatment of aseptic femoral nonunions: Report of two cases and literature review.

Treatment of Distal Femoral Nonunion and Delayed Union by Using a Retrograde Intramedullary Interlocking Nail.

Functional Outcome of Solid Interlocking Nail in Open Tibial Fracture at a Tertiary Care Center: A Descriptive Cross-sectional Study

AO Expert Tibial Intramedullary Nailing for Minimally Invasive Treatment of Distal Metaphyseal Tibial Fractures

Aseptic femoral nonunion treated with exchange locked nailing with intramedullary augmentation cancellous bone graft

Management of Femoral Diaphyseal Nonunion after Nailing with Augmentative Locked Plating and Bone Graft