Birthweight ratio.

A. Lucas,R. Morley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/adc.66.9.1099-b
1991-09-01
Archives of Disease in Childhood
Abstract:SIR,-Dr Field et al are not justified in concluding from the data presented that there should be a more centralised service for babies of 28 weeks' gestation or less.' They found that babies of 28 weeks' gestation or less treated in large centres had higher survival rates than those treated in smaller units. It is likely that this is due to selection in the smaller units of appropriate babies to refer to the large centres. Data from our unit, which is in the Trent region, were included in the report. We have a policy of transferring babies of 28 weeks' gestation or less to a regional centre. Two categories of babies are not transferred: firstly babies who are so ill that they do not survive long enough to be transferred or are not likely to survive transfer, and secondly babies who are considered previable. During the time of the study, three babies of 28 weeks' gestation or less were not referred from our unit to a large centre, but remained in our unit for terminal care. These were a second twin of 26 weeks' gestation with severe birth asphyxia and asystole at birth who died at 1 hour 20 minutes after unsuccessful resuscitation attempts, an infant of 24 weeks' gestation, and an infant of 21 weeks' gestation. During the same period we referred postnatally 12 babies of 28 weeks' gestation or less to a large centre for neonatal intensive care. Four of these babies died. Clearly the difference in outcome for these two groups of babies is due to selection bias. It is likely that similar decisions were taken in other smaller units in the region and comparison of survival in the two types of units is therefore not valid. We believe that it is in the interest of selected very immature babies in our unit that we should transfer them to a large neonatal centre for intensive care. The results of this policy will be that those infants of 28 weeks' gestation or less who we do not transfer may well be receiving terminal care in our unit. It must not be concluded that these babies would have had a better chance of survival or better care had they been transferred to a large centre.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?