Abstract:The computer security research community regularly tackles ethical questions. The field of ethics / moral philosophy has for centuries considered what it means to be "morally good" or at least "morally allowed / acceptable". Among philosophy's contributions are (1) frameworks for evaluating the morality of actions -- including the well-established consequentialist and deontological frameworks -- and (2) scenarios (like trolley problems) featuring moral dilemmas that can facilitate discussion about and intellectual inquiry into different perspectives on moral reasoning and decision-making. In a classic trolley problem, consequentialist and deontological analyses may render different opinions. In this research, we explicitly make and explore connections between moral questions in computer security research and ethics / moral philosophy through the creation and analysis of trolley problem-like computer security-themed moral dilemmas and, in doing so, we seek to contribute to conversations among security researchers about the morality of security research-related decisions. We explicitly do not seek to define what is morally right or wrong, nor do we argue for one framework over another. Indeed, the consequentialist and deontological frameworks that we center, in addition to coming to different conclusions for our scenarios, have significant limitations. Instead, by offering our scenarios and by comparing two different approaches to ethics, we strive to contribute to how the computer security research field considers and converses about ethical questions, especially when there are different perspectives on what is morally right or acceptable.

Ethical reasoning methods for ICT: What they are and when to use them

Ethical Underpinnings in the Design and Management of ICT Projects

The Power of Ethics: Uncovering Technology Risks and Positive Value Potentials in IT Innovation Planning

Surveying the Landscape of Ethics-Focused Design Methods

Ethical, Legal and Social aspects of Information and Communication Technology

Critical Requirements Engineering in Practice

Usages et conception des TIC : Proposition d'un modèle d'aide à la représentation de problème de conception

Comprehensive training guidelines from ethical research associated with information and communication technology and artificial intelligence

Ethical Implications of IT-enabled Information Flows Conceived as Intermediaries or Mediators

Metacognitive Agents for Ethical Decision Support: Conceptual Model and Research Roadmap

Model-Guided Fieldwork: A Practical, Methodological and Philosophical Investigation in the use of Ethnomethodology for Engineering Software Requirements

Ethical Frameworks and Computer Security Trolley Problems: Foundations for Conversations

A Methodology for Assessing the Environmental Effects Induced by ICT Services. Part I: Single Services

Ethical framework for Artificial Intelligence and Digital technologies

ICT Evaluation: Are We Asking the Right Questions?

Thinging Ethics for Software Engineers

Conceptualizing development in information and communication technology for development (ICT4D)

Where have all the equations gone? A unified view on semi-quantitative problem structuring and modelling

Socio-inspired ICT - Towards a socially grounded society-ICT symbiosis

ICT4D evaluation: its foci, challenges, gaps, limitations, and possible approaches for improvement

How do Computer Science Students Make Decisions in Ethical Situations? Implications for Teaching Computing Ethics based on a Grounded Theory Study