From Correspondenzblatt to BJS – a century of Swiss surgical publishing
F. Harder,A. Leutenegger,P. Clavien
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/BJS.4487
2004-01-01
Abstract:With journals and newspapers one tends to develop a special personal relationship of affection or aversion, of trust or scepticism, of enthusiasm or indifference. With some preferred periodicals one is proud to have been not merely a passive reader but also an active contributor. The best journals, the most cherished ones, regularly find their way into surgical libraries and are thoroughly discussed in journal clubs, which are, in essence, ‘critical fan clubs’. It is only natural, therefore, that the disappearance of an appreciated journal will not go unnoticed, even more so when that journal has been part of a national surgical lifestyle and tradition. Still, as we have repeatedly experienced with journals in Switzerland and in the Swiss Society of Surgery, after a period of mourning another strong relationship will develop that is adapted to new environmental factors. In the Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte of 1893 (no. 21) it was stated that ‘Swiss academic medical circles have for many years been exploring the idea, first presented in Berne, of creating a common (i.e. medical and surgical) periodical for publishing scientific contributions that could not be published in the Correspondenzblatt or in the Revue Médicale due to their volume and content, and that these medical publications would find their way to foreign countries’. Clearly the leaders of that time placed a strong emphasis on preserving a competitive national identity when it came to reporting progress and achievement in medicine and surgery, a point of view that can be followed right through to today. The Mitteilungen aus Kliniken und medizinischen Instituten der Schweiz appeared during the autumn of that very year of 1893. Among its initiators were prestigious names such as Theodor Kocher of Berne and César Roux of Lausanne. Sadly, despite outstanding contributions, this first attempt at preventing a drain of valuable scientific information to the journals of foreign countries survived for only 3 years. When the Swiss Society of Surgery was founded on 8 March 1913, its president was Theodor Kocher (1841–1917), the first surgeon to win a Nobel Prize (in 1909). His address was published in the well established Correspondenzblatt der Schweizer Aerzte (no. 43). In 1920 this journal became the Schweizerische Medizinische Wochenschrift, which continued to publish the scientific activities of the Swiss Society of Surgery, among other things. In 1934 a new medical journal, Helvetica Medica Acta, was founded in response to a need to report a variety of scientific and medical information. No less than César Roux of Lausanne, Fritz de Quervain of Berne and Eugen Bircher of Aarau represented surgery on its inaugural editorial board. In the face of specialization in all fields of medicine, in 1944 the Swiss Society of Surgery started its own, strictly surgical, archives – Helvetica Chirurgica Acta. This periodical, with articles in German or French, was published regularly until 1994. Over its 50 years of publication it contained important contributions from eminent Swiss surgical units, presented by leaders such as Ferdinand Sauerbruch, Alfred Brunner and Ake Senning from Zurich, Fritz de Quervain from Berne, J. C. Rudler from Geneva, Rudolf Nissen and Martin Allgöwer from Basle, and many others. Today, equivalent papers would find their way directly into outstanding international journals. With the rapid evolution of new fields in surgery and the increased availability of journals well suited to the needs of various specialties, ambitious young Swiss surgeons began to seek their own professional identity and recognition. To express the latter objectively in a measurable manner, the computation of accumulated impact factor points became the accepted way of quantifying surgical contributions from both individuals and surgical departments. Important original work would no longer be submitted to Helvetica Chirurgica Acta, unless the authors were willing to forego the opportunity of publishing their work in well indexed international journals. Helvetica Chirurgica Acta was in trouble! It had existed for 50 years and had served both as a broad national forum for young surgeons and as a highly valued instrument of education, allowing surgeons to communicate with one another inside the Swiss surgical community and across cultural, linguistic and sometimes hierarchical obstacles. More than just a leading scientific publication, Helvetica Chirurgica Acta was a