Abstract:Social-evaluative threat (SET) - when the self could be negatively judged by others - can cause pronounced responses in the different stress systems: threat/challenge appraisal, the sympathetic (SNS) and parasympathetic (PNS) nervous systems, experienced motivation and affect, and the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis. Here, we utilize a four-stage stress response model to shed light on the complex associations between different stress responses, where earlier stages are hypothesized to predict later stages. Additionally, we take into account important moderators, such as biological sex (controlling for menstrual cycle phase), personality traits (neuroticism and extraversion), and baseline stress levels. Thirty-seven men and 30 women in their luteal phase participated in an impromptu public speaking task to induce SET. Stress responses in four different stages were measured using: self-reported appraisal (threat or challenge, stage 1: S1), cardiovascular measures (pre-ejection period as SNS index, respiratory sinus arrhythmia as PNS index, S2), self-reported motivation and affect (state approach motivation, state anxiety, S3) and endocrine measures (cortisol as HPA index, S4). Stress reactivity was calculated by subtracting individual peaks from baseline. Results showed that SET induced pronounced stress reactivity in stages two to four. Against expectations, self-reported appraisal (S1) or motivation and affect (S3) did not predict later stress reactivity. As hypothesized, increased SNS (but not PNS) reactivity (S2) predicted increased HPA reactivity (S4). Bayesian model comparison confirmed the absence of sex differences in stress reactivity, likely due to controlling for menstrual cycle phase and sex differences in neuroticism levels. Higher trait neuroticism predicted blunted SNS (S2) and HPA (S4) reactivity, while higher baseline stress levels predicted blunted stages two and three reactivity overall. In conclusion, this rigorously controlled experiment partly supports and partly contradicts previous findings regarding associations between stress response stages, and offers new insight into the causes of blunted HPA responses in women.

Social-evaluative threat: Stress response stages and influences of biological sex and neuroticism

Sex Hormones Affect Acute and Chronic Stress Responses in Sexually Dimorphic Patterns: Consequences for Depression Models

Sex differences in the stress response in SD rats.

Sex and stress: Men and women show different cortisol responses to psychological stress induced by the Trier social stress test and the Iowa singing social stress test

Depressive and Anxious Symptoms, Experimentally Manipulated Acute Social-Evaluative Threat, and Cortisol Reactivity

Stress appraisal is associated with sympathetic neural reactivity to mental stress in humans

Individual Differences in the Correspondence Between Psychological and Physiological Stress Indicators

Personality and physiological reactions to acute psychological stress

Effects of gender and personality on everyday moral decision-making after acute stress exposure

When the mind says one thing, but the HPA axis says another: Lack of coherence between subjective and neuroendocrine stress response trajectories in healthy men

Individual differences in parasympathetic nervous system reactivity in response to everyday stress are associated with momentary emotional exhaustion

The relationship between personality and the response to acute psychological stress

Global stress response during a social stress test: impact of alexithymia and its subfactors

Sex Differences in Stress Response: Classical Mechanisms and Beyond

Autonomic reactivity during acute social stress: exploratory investigation of an interaction by threat interpretation bias and emotion regulation difficulties

Sex differences in stress reactivity in arousal and attention systems

Gender Difference in Neural Response to Psychological Stress.

The Influence of Menstrual Cycle and Androstadienone on Female Stress Reactions: An fMRI Study

Neuroendocrine stress response is moderated by sex and sex hormone receptor polymorphisms

Immune-neuroendocrine patterning and response to stress. A latent profile analysis in the English longitudinal study of ageing

Multi-systemic evaluation of biological and emotional responses to the Trier Social Stress Test: A meta-analysis and systematic review