Action and learning for safer healthcare systems.

A. Siriwardena

Quality in Primary Care

Abstract:Two key reports have been published over the past few weeks in response to the Francis Report on the MidStaffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry and a third report has addressed the issue of failing hospitals in England. The UK government’s initial response to the Francis report, Patients First and Foremost and the report from Don Berwick and the National Advisory Group, Improving the Safety of Patients in England both seek to address the key quality issues for all health systems of safety, effectiveness and experience, and both emphasise a systemwide response, but they take different approaches to addressing these issues. The government’s response focuses on regulation, measurement, monitoring and accountability to prevent, detect and address problems promptly; there is a focus on training and revalidation of nurses and healthcare assistants, and continued support for leadership training and executive boards. There is recognition that the regulatory and inspection system needs to be improved, that data need to be used more effectively, and that transparency and openness should be supported. Despite references to ‘the system’ and ‘working together’, the report lacks a coherent approach that addresses the whole system from patients and their relatives to government and the framework in which they operate. The report’s approach to education and training is somewhat narrowly focused on training, supervision and regulation of healthcare assistants and nurses. The Berwick Report is more succinct but is clearer on what needs to be done across the whole system. Its overarching aim that ‘the NHS should continually and forever reduce patient harm by embracing wholeheartedly an ethic of learning’ focuses on safety, but the subsequent recommendations also address the domains of patient experience and clinical effectiveness. The recommendations are the distillation of many decades’ experience of research into quality and safety by an expert group of scientists, patients and managers which formulates a set of principles and actions for improving quality and safety in the NHS. The Berwick Report explicitly recognises that the health service is a system, and so each aim is translated into recommendations addressed to various actors in the system from patients, healthcare workers, health organisations and regulators to the government. There is also recognition that many of the elements of an excellent system are in place already – and that what is less evident now is how these elements should cooperate and interact better to provide a safer health system. The areas that are focused on by Berwick are critically important for safety and quality: